Wednesday, August 06, 2008
-
Minister Dresses Up as a Homeless Man...Churchgoers Ignore Him
from pass_the_aura
There are teachable moments.... and then there are Teachable Moments. This utter gem of a story appeared in The Telegraph a few weeks ago (link here).
Church minister shames congregation by dressing as tramp
Churchgoers were left shamed after they ignored a tramp who turned out to be their minister in disguise
By Martin Beckford, Religious Affairs CorrespondentThe Rev Derek Rigby sat in the porch to his church as the congregation arrived for a Sunday service, hidden beneath a wig and scruffy clothes.
He then settled on a pew in the church surrounded by syringes and began drinking from a can of beer.
But none of the worshippers at the Trinity Methodist Church in Prestatyn, North Wales, spoke to him or offered him any help.
The 51-year-old then took off his wig to reveal his true identity, before delivering a sermon based on the failure of the disciples to recognise Jesus Christ on the road to Emmaus after his resurrection.
Rev Rigby said: "It was interesting to see the reaction from people - I was totally ignored.
"It showed that we don't recognise God at work and in each other."Rev Rigby, who was a police officer for 15 years before being ordained 20 years ago, has tricked congregations in the same way at his previous parishes in London and Newport, South Wales.
He said: "In other places I was given as much as £4.50, a packet of biscuits and a blanket - but in Prestatyn I got nothing.
"I told the congregation they are a stingy lot.
"Everyone was amazed and later complimented me on my acting skill, though some said I had made them feel terrible."
Describing how he avoided detection, he said: "I didn't shave for three days, made my hands and face dirty and drew on tattoos.
"I bought some scruffy clothes at a charity shop, ripped the trousers, and put on a straggly wig and thick, broken glasses.
"I then splashed lager over my clothes so I was stinking.
"I looked in the mirror before the service and I didn't recognise myself."
Chuchgoer John Sproston was one of the first to arrive at the service to see the "tramp" on the doorstep.
He said: "We were all aghast when he took off his wig because he was very convincing."
* * *
For if a man wearing a gold ring and fine clothing comes into your assembly, and a poor man in shabby clothing also comes in, and if you pay attention to the one who wears the fine clothing and say, “You sit here in a good place,” while you say to the poor man, “You stand over there,” or, “Sit down at my feet,” have you not then made distinctions among yourselves and become judges with evil thoughts?
--James 2:2-4How would you react if this happened at YOUR church?
Post a Comment
- Back to revelife's Revelife Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in revelife's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)







Comments (91)
At our last missions convention, our Master's Commission (college program) dressed up as Indian beggars and begged in our lobby and in the church bathrooms. It was awesome, actually.
this is very sad. shameful. i'm glad that the pastor made some of his congregation feel terrible.
heartbreaking. that's awful.
I would've asked if he wanted something to eat, taken him to the kitchen of the church and fed the guy. I would have also tried to look for the pastor to see if we could take up an offering for the guy to stay overnight at a hotel (to get a shower)...and get him cleaned up with some 2nd hand clothes.
(I've been able to do the first part many times...but not successful on the later portions)
I think more pastor's should teach like this...that's pretty cool.
I've noticed that almost all recognizably new visitors in our church are welcomed by somebody, but we've never had a homeless person come to my church that I know of. It's hard to say what we'd do.
If that happened at my parent's home church they would probably have kicked him out because, you know, he's making the uber rich look bad by being there.
I hate my parent's home church.
We actually have people like that all the time in our church. Our church is really involved with the homeless and needy people of our community, so it wouldn't phase anyone in our church to see someone in the congregation who is homeless, drunk, high, or whatever. It's just part of the experience at our church.
Another spin on the same 'act':
I knew a pastor who appeared as a homeless man on the steps of other local churches asking every passerby to help him find God. He appeared at the same church for three weeks and then on the fourth week he re-appeared in suit and tie preaching the gospel as the same 'church' people who couldn't help him in the previous three weeks entered their 'place of worship'. Once again, shaming and angering 'church people'.
My church would have a party. Small methodist congregation who welcomes everyone--we'd all befriend him and take him down to the kitchen, get him fed, scrounge up some better clothes and some towels to wash up, then come back upstairs, introduce him as our new friend, Mr. So-and-So, and invite him to worship with us. The offering would probably be taken for him. I go to an amazingly tolerant and giving church.
This doesn't surprise me in the least. You don't have to dress up like a beggar to be ignored, or even shunned outright, in a church. Just be someone who doesn't fit into a neat little box as it were. Just be someone to whom the standard Christian cannot affix a neat little label. Christians are loathe to leave their comfort zones in order to minister to the individuals who need ministering to the most.
Add to that that most churches are run like businesses with an eye to the bottom line, therefore judging anyone warming their pews with an eye to potential profitability, and there you go.
I have seen this in action. From both sides of the situation.
To people who are going through a lot and come to church to seek God as a last resort (which is often the case) Christians seem cold or else very condescending.
@Pariahtich@xanga - This is true of some churches, but not all; mine, for instance, isn't like this.
Of course there are some people who wouldn't help or accept someone, but there are many others who would. We can't help having a mix, since it is a large church (about 2,000 people).
And yet you all wonder why non-Christians have a poor view of Christians! This is an excellent example of experiences that we have all had, clearly showing that some people are just hypocrites.
@Nikolais_apprentice@xanga -
Wow...I wish I lived in your area. Your church sounds amazing. I know that not all churches are cold. It's just churches like that are a rare find. Gratz on being so blessed
@Pariahtich@xanga - Mhmm, it was truly a blessing to find. Such wonderful people! I wish more people got a chance to have that experience.
@la_faerie_joyeuse@xanga - I think non-Christians will always have a poor view of Christians.
One problem is, we all start off in different places.
Person A may be a jerk and a Christian. Person B may be nice and not a Christian.
However, Person A may have come from a horrible situation, and it is impossible for other people to see how far they have already come because they still have far to go.
Person B may be nice simply because they are naturally nice, had a nice family, etc. Person B may seem "more Christian" because we can't see people's hearts, only their outsides.
I believe Christians should help people and that it is totally wrong to turn anyone away or look down on anyone. But I don't believe that is really the main reason people dislike Christians. I believe the main reason is Christ.
Jesus said, "If the world hates you, keep in mind that it hated me first.
If you belonged to the world, it would love you as its own. As it is, you do not belong to the world, but I have chosen you out of the world. That is why the world hates you. (John 15:18-19)
And John wrote, "Do not be surprised, my brothers, if the world hates you." (1 John 3:13)
People will cite different reasons for hating Christians: hypocrisy, fakeness, stinginess, etc., but those issues reflect experiences with certain Christians, not all Christians, and to label the whole group with those things is stereotyping. I believe Christians in general are disliked because of the message of Christ. Christians (at least most) don't claim perfection; we just claim to know the Person who can heal our imperfection, and people get angered by that claim.
Getting out of rant-mode now
I would feel betrayed, lied to...etc.
@la_faerie_joyeuse@xanga - Especially that pastor, exposing the truth and encouraging people to love their neighbors and everything. Man....
It's saddening that a majority of today's "Christians" seem to be only worried/thinking about themselves and not about the people around them, whom they do not know.
Come on . . . the guy's drinking a Foster's. Even Satan won't turn his back on a guy drinking a Foster's. That's some good beer, mate!
i like this guy. what a potent way to get your point across.
@la_faerie_joyeuse@xanga - Who says we wonder?
On the other hand, your ignorance explains why we expect the world to treat us badly regardless of how much like Christ we are.
That's a harsh way to get a point across but it does prove the point exactly. We too many times walk past that person on the street because of what they "may" do with the money you give them, or you make a choice that they probably don't really need the money so why should i part with some of mine for them. I've done the right thing and the wrong thing, probalby too many times on the wrong. I don't know how I would react to someone sitting on the doorstep at my church, but after reading this I would surely invite them in and try to connect them with someone in our recovery ministry. I always remember something that Jesus said something like, to whatever you've done for the least of these you've done to me". I personally think that was a good message and point for this pastor to do, conviction helps make some people get out of their comfort zones.
@Pickwick12@xanga - I think a lot of Christians have a poor view of Christians. I'm one of them. There's hope for us, but I think we deserve a lot of the criticism we get.
@GodArt@xanga - I agree that some of the criticism is warranted. However, I still believe that the main reason people dislike Christians as a whole group is because the message of the cross is foolishness to them.
In a sense, I think I have the poorest view of Christians it's possible to have-I don't believe we have anything to offer in ourselves without Christ.
I heard about this a few weeks ago...
I actually just finished writing a post about the homeless....
but I plan on doing a more serious post on my Revelife site.
Personally, I like to help people out, so I probably would have offered him something- probably to buy him some food.
Maybe they thought he was a trannie? Better yet maybe they knew it was him?