By Dean LuskYesterday I was struck with a serious question. I had no choice but to
Facebook for my very best friends to consider. You may have read it already:
If "I don't want a lot for Christmas," yet "all I want for Christmas is you," isn't that song ultimately one big insult?
With that, you can probably guess that "All I Want for Christmas is You" handily earns a spot in the list of my least favorite Christmas songs of all time. This isn't an easy list for me to make because I'm so opinionated. Lots of songs should make the list, but only five lucky ones will.
By the way, I thought about making this post about favorite Christmas songs, but that's just not as fun.
I'll be focusing on popular Christmas songs; not the obscure tunes that almost everyone hates. There's a high probability that you will like -- nay, even love -- multiple songs on my list. I'm willing to take that chance.
So without further ado, here is
The Dean's List: My Five Least Favorite Christmas Songs of All Time (if you'd like to purchase any of these stinkers for whatever weird and disturbed reason, I've linked them to MP3's at Amazon.com):
- All I Want for Christmas is You
- The Christmas Shoes
- All I Want for Christmas Is My Two Front Teeth
- Last Christmas
- Santa Claus is Coming to Town (the butchered Jackson 5/Bruce Springsteen, etc. version, NOT the unassailable classic song upon which Arthur Rankin, Jr. and Jules Bass based their gripping drama of the same name.)
I've chosen one song on the list to explain its inclusion. Ranting about each song would be very impractical from a time standpoint. I'd be here too long. Let's run with Newsong's "The Christmas Shoes" (who knew the title had "The" in it?):
There is so much I want to say about this song. It's possibly the most contrived urban legend I've ever heard, which is how this song unfortunately came to life (some will argue that it's based on a true story. I don't believe that for a moment). Shoes?? For a kid's dying mother? I probably shouldn't state the obvious, but very likely, well... she's not going to have an opportunity to wear them. And it's
Christmas Eve! The boy should be at his mom's bedside, not leeching off of some stranger on the street. The lone child singing the last line is consumer manipulation at its worst. I can almost hear the producer saying to his associates in the recording studio, "You know what will really get 'em?
We'll have a kid sing the last line!" and everybody in the room breaks into kudos for this bit of unexpected production genius.
Enough of that. You get the idea. Now, if my list were, say, a "Top Eight" list, I could easily think of three more songs. Since this is a "Top Five" list, though, I have to make a whole new one:
The Dean's List: I Really Dislike These Christmas Songs, As Well:
- Little St. Nick (my daughter loves this song. I feel terrible having it on my list)
- I Want a Hippopotamus for Christmas (same comment as the previous song)
- Hey, Santa (this apparently isn't the correct name, but I believe these are the first lyrics in the song. A little help?)
The floor is openfor you to share your list or just to give me some serious grief for dissing your favorite Christmas song!
Comments (16)
This year Christmas songs have been played since the day after halloween. I'm so sick of them.
I'll try to narrow it down to five.
1. Hey Santa.
2. All I want for Christmas is my two front teeth.
3. I'm not sure of the title but Bing Crobsy is singing about a Hawaiian Christmas
4. Christmas in Kilarney
Tie -5. Frosty the snowman and Rudolph. I've heard too many versions of these songs. It ruins it.
I agree with the original list in the entry. Yuck. If the choice is up to me, the radio wouldn't even come on at this time of year. I'll stick with the 20 or so Christmas songs I have mixed in along with both regular Christian and secular music on my music player.
I'm not sure I can come up with 5. I absolutely love Christmas, and I listen to christmas music all year round. I also really enjoy parody's and crazy Christmas music.
While some might say Silent Night is their favorite, I might be listening to it put to polka music, being sung by dancing reindeer. I don't actually own such a song, don't worry.
I do own
"Leroy the redneck reindeer" by Joe Diffie
"Santa I'm right here" by Toby Keith (btw it is just as sappy as The Christmas Shoes)
"The Christmas Shoes" By Newsong
I own more typical Christmas songs too like O little town of bethleham, but it was recorded in the 50's off an LP and not in stereo.
If I had to come up with some sort list of least favorite Christmas music, I would have to go with "Belleau wood" by Garth Brooks, and "The Little Drummer Boy" by anyone, I cannot stand this one.
"If "I don't want a lot for Christmas," yet "all I want for Christmas is you," isn't that song ultimately one big insult?"
I think you misjudged the song. I always took the line about not wanting a lot, to be quantity not quality. the song is not saying the "you" is not "a lot" the song is saying the person only wants 1 thing and that is you
Grandma got run over by a reindeer. How is that even funny?!
Oh my gosh! Thanks for posting this so I can share how sick I am of
Santa BabySanta Claus is Coming to TownUp on the RooftopIt's the Most Wonderful Time of Year
1. Hey Santa 2. Santa Baby 3. Baby It's Cold Outside 4. I Saw Mommy Kissing Santa Claus 5. Little Altar Boy
Least favourite Christmas song? Pretty much anything written after the 19th century (the two exceptions being "I Wonder as I Wander" and "Carol of the Bells"). I'm very, very traditional when it comes to Christmas music. If it isn't sung by a choir or played with an orchestra, then chances are I won't like it.
Songs about reindeer and Santa and winter wonderlands? No thanks. I'll be in the corner listening to "O Come, O Come Emmanuel", "God Rest Ye Merry, Gentlemen", "Good King Wenceslas", and "The First Nowell". Even if it's in the middle of July. XP
- The resident Christmas-loving atheist.
@Syphan@xanga - when/if my follow-up is posted here ("Your Five Favorite Christmas Songs?") you'll find that we have some similar tastes. Thanks for getting the comma in the right place on "God Rest Ye Merry, Gentlemen", by the way.
Thanks for all the lists! You guys named some more of my least favorites. One thing confounds me... I can't figure out why I don't dislike the 5,043 versions of "Baby, It's Cold Outside".
Wow! Good lists! There is a verse to one particular Christmas song I just can't comprehend. You guys remember that song " Do They Know It's Christmas"? What was that for BandAid or something Aid? Well back to the point------ There is a verse in a that song that goes "Well tonight thank God it's them instead of you"....
Wtf? Seriously .... would you really be happy that others are starving/no gifts etc at Christmas and not you? How selfish... Kind of contradicts the purpose of that whole Band Aid thingy if you ask me. Oh well that was 27 yrs ago.
Many of those previously mentioned are on my shi* list too. Especially "Grandma got runover by a reindeer.".... yeesh...
How about a twist, name a few that are not well known, but that are awesome songs?
Leroy the Redneck Reindeer. Good music, good video. Youtube it.
Santa Claus to the tune of Iron Man-Black Sabbath... again, youtube it.
Several of the Bob Rivers Twisted Christmas album...Chipmunks roasting on an open fire, Walkin round in womens underwear, (Walkin in a winter wonderland), Police Stop my Car (Feliz Navidad) again, youtube is your friend...
I hate Santa Baby. So creepy.
And "Baby It's Cold Outside" sounds like the guy is trying to drug up the girl. Also shady.
@rainthesnowaway@lovelyish - Wait... "It's the Most Wonderful Time of the Year" is on your hate list?!
Well, you're obviously not wrong. After all, you're the one who knows your own opinion.
It's that hippo song I dislike...very much. o_e
But if it said zebra or a dragon, or a dinosaur....I wouldn't mind so much.
hehee
OwO
Men speak quite unexpected: "Are you okay?" ANike Air Max 2012woman is surprised: "Fortunately, I have been asleep not to say that the morning and then call you?" Men do not seem to be assured that they asked one: "Are you okay?"woman some funny, this man is too sentimental a, although know that he is concerned about their own," I of course nothing, fast asleep. howChristian Louboutin Cheapdo you? "a man said:" you say soon, I have been to the. do not worry.something do not forget to give me a call. "and then he told the woman Road Good Night, and hurry to hang up the phone.
Air Force 1
Air Force 1 All-Star
Air Force 1 Bespoke
Air Force 1 High
Air Force 1 Low
Air Force 1 Mid
Air Force 1 Womens
Air Jordan
Jordan 1
Jordan 11
Jordan 12
Jordan 13
Jordan 14
Jordan 18
Jordan 19
Jordan 2
Jordan 2012
Jordan 23
Jordan 3
Jordan 4
Jordan 5
Jordan 6
Jordan 7
Jordan 8
Jordan 9
Jordan Alpha Trunner
Jordan CMFT
Jordan CP3.IV
Jordan Evolution '85
Jordan Fly 23
Jordan Fly Wade
Jordan Melo M7
Jordan Play In These F
Jordan Prime 5
Jordan SC-2
Jordan Spizikes
Jordan Take Flight
Air Presto
Air Shox HyperBaller
Air Vengeance
Air Yeezy
Air Yeezy
Air Yeezy 2
Air Yeezy Womens
Ken Griffey Womens
Nike Air Griffey Max 1
Nike Air Griffey Max GD II
Nike Air Griffey Max II
Nike Air Max 1
Nike Air Max 2012
Nike Air Max 2012 Womens
Nike Air Max 24/7
Nike Air Max 360
Nike Air Max 90
Nike Air Max 90 Hyperfuse
Nike Air Max 90 Premium
Nike Air Max 90 VT
Nike Air Max 95
Nike Air Max Barkley
NIKE Air Max Fly By
Nike Air Max Griffey Fury
Nike Air Max Jr
Nike Air Max Nomo
Nike Air Max Penny 1
Nike Air Max Tailwind
Nike Air Max Uptempo 2
Nike Air Max Uptempo 97
Nike Air Max Wavy
Nike Air Max2 CB 94
Nike Air More Uptempo
Nike Air Penny
Nike Air Structure Triax 91
Nike Air Total Max Uptempo
Nike Air Trainer Max 2 '94
Nike Free
Nike LeBron
LeBron 8
LeBron 9
Nike Lunar
Nike Skateboarding
SB Eric Koston
SB P-Rod
SB Paul Rodriguez
SB Stefan Janoski
Nike Zoom
SB Zoom Bruin
Zoom Huarache
Zoom Hyperdunk
Zoom Hyperfuse
Zoom Rookie Lwp
SB Stefan Janoski Khaki Gum
SB Stefan Janoski Pacific Blue White
SB Zoom Janoski Teal Abyss
SB Zoom Stefan Janoski Black Midnight Fog
SB Zoom Stefan Janoski Black White
SB Zoom Stefan Janoski Mid Black White
SB Zoom Stefan Janoski Mid Camel
SB Zoom Stefan Janoski Mid Dark Brown Black White
SB Zoom Stefan Janoski Red Suede
SB Zoom Stefan Janoski Tan Brown
SB Zoom Stefan Janoski White Perf
SB Zoom Stefan Janoski Wine Red White
Zoom Stefan Janoski SB Brown White
Zoom Stefan Janoski SB Khaki Boulder
Zoom Stefan Janoski SB Leather Bisque White
Zoom Stefan Janoski SB Obsidian White Metro Grey
Nike Air Max 360 BB Low All-Star East
Nike Air Max 360 BB Low All-Star West
Nike Air Max 360 BB Low White/Cool Grey-Electric Green
Nike Air Max 360 BB Low White/Orange
Nike Air Max 2012 Black/Pure Platinum-Black
Nike Air Max 2012 Mango
Nike Air Max 2012 Volt/University Red
Nike Air Max 2012 White/Blue Spark
Primary school, we are at the same table, weNike Free Run 2are together every day, classmates always make fun of us, our childhood, I've never really had, but you seriously. You oftenNike Free Runsaid to me: "We want to be together forever, okay?" I nodded, because I had always thought that we exist only innocence, most of the best friendship.I would like to if we are together, we can live every day like a child always happy, you cling on my right, I am on your leftChristian Louboutin Shoeswith us hippie smile, doing homework together, came home from school together ... Our departure came so suddenly, because we did not considerChristian Louboutin On Saleeach other to leave the moment. Moment, but eventually came, I followed the teacher, there are several other studentsChristian Louboutin Outletto participate in the county's well-known secondary school examination, and you no go. Later, I was admitted, and from this we also separated the two.