Saturday, 29 January 2011
-
My Panic Attack at Church
The first time I had a panic attack I was sitting through a sermon at church. It was my parent’s church, and the church I went to growing up. I was 18 and home for the summer after my freshman year away at college.
The event was reminiscent of a scene from an amateur exorcism flick—the setting ironically quaint, sun shining through the windows on a beautiful June Sunday morning whilst a charismatic preacher waxed rhetorical fairy dust into the atmosphere.
I played the lead role of nerd-gone-wild. Picture something like a modern adaptation of Arthur Miller’s The Crucible. Instead of 12-year-old girls unwittingly tripping out on bacteria-ridden English muffins, you have me, a scrawny teenager pathetically suffocating under the weight of his own ribcage.
The previous school year had been semi-traumatic and laid the foundation for the peculiarity of this event. Due to my college budget and an opportunity cost analysis that repeatedly left me picking sleep over time that could otherwise have been spent cooking, I slowly weaned myself off of every food category on the pyramid save for sugar and caffeine. Over time this limited diet left me with two physiological conditions: a nervous system fully dependent on caffeine in order to function and blood sugar levels teetering on the brink of diabetic collapse.
My psychological constitution was equally wanting. When I got to college, I went a little crazy. I obsessed over my workload and evaluated the quality of my work in terms of extremes—for me, it was either A quality or failing quality. I didn’t so much desire perfection as much as I feared failure. Although literally failing out of school was such an unlikely situation, the mere possibility of it occurring—and what I viewed as the devastating results that would follow (ex. homelessness)—scared me out of my mind.
Most people think that Obsessive Compulsive Disorder refers to a condition in which the afflicted has an obsession with cleanliness, tidiness, symmetry, or numbers (or something to this effect). Although this is sometimes the case, the underlying problem is actually that of irrational fear. Legitimate fears warrant due concern and no one thinks any different, but irrational fears draw attention. If you’re worried that the world will end if you don’t count to three, you have an obsession. If you actually count to three to prevent the world from ending, you have a compulsion—and vwahla, OCD.
Freshmen year I had an irrational fear (obsession) that I was going to fail life in general, school in particular. This caused me many sleepless nights and, subsequently, introduced me to a new friend named Ambien. My response to the anxiety I experienced was to seclude myself in the library for 12 hours at a time (compulsive) in order to get my work done. Anytime I wasn’t working on school I was thinking about working on school. Fun was an opportunity cost I just wasn’t sure I could afford, no matter how many times I decided to buy it.
As a result of this process, I grew to resent school. I did not enjoy it; I hated it. It was the primary source of my sufferings and I eventually became very depressed.
By the time I found myself in the aforementioned church service, I was in an existential bind. It turns out that school, and the stress it caused me, were only a catalyst for the start of a much deeper depression that I continued to suffer from after the spring semester and throughout the summer I spent at home. I reached the worst kind of depression; it was generally inexplicable. My body and soul felt so low (it’s the best way I can put it), and what’s worse, I was getting used to it.
Depression can very much become an addiction. It may be uncomfortable and certainly painful, but it’s also attractive as a sedative; it’s familiar and easily accessible. It takes discipline and work to stay positive in a world that’s generally chaotic and seemingly random—at least for a depressive. But it takes almost no work to wallow in despair—it’s a passive act.
For simplicity’s sake: I’ll define despair as a loss of hope. That summer I had lost at lot of hope in life. More so, I had lost hope in myself. I convinced myself that the exercise of my free will was a greater force acting towards my ultimate demise than God’s providence a force counter-acting toward my redemption. I wanted happiness but I convinced myself that happiness was ignorance. I believed God was real and alive but I believed he offered no guarantee that my life would be better, or happy, or joyful in this life. Heaven sounded great but simply a consolation for death, which was probably a long way off. What would satiate the longings of my soul for the next 60 years? [For an excellent reading on this topic read N.T. Wright’s Surprised by Hope]
The sermon topic on this Sunday morning was—maybe ironically—“Finding Joy in the Christian Life.” I wish I could tell you that God met me in that sermon, that my pissed off frown turned upside down. But it didn’t. I listened as the pastor went on about how if you're not happy with your life, you simply don't understand grace; you haven't been "swept up in the love of Christ"--whatever that meant. The way he spoke discounted the notion that there exists any sort of depression separate from spiritual depression-- and even in the case of spiritual depression he simply attributed the problem with not having read the right verses on "joy" in the Bible.
What about a depression that overtakes you even when you're crying out to God the most? What about a depression with seemingly no origin. What about a depression that is probably more than likely attributable, in part, to a chemical imbalance in your brain, the kind that desensitizes you to that tingly feeling you get when your pastor flings cocaine-laced verbiage at you from the pulpit. What I heard that morning was not a sermon, but a eulogy. How could this Gospel be life-giving--it was powerless. He killed it.
For a moment I entertained the possibility that he was right, that the depression I suffered from was entirely my fault. Jesus died for me, I simply have to think more positively. In my current state of mind, this was not an option for me. If Christianity was flipping on the happy switch, then not only could I not do it, I wanted nothing of it. And if that was the case, I had serious reason to panic, because then I really did have no hope, and I was probably going to hell.
My panic attack caused a bit of a scene, and it lasted a long time, but I eventually recovered. I stopped entertaining the possibility that that preacher was right; I realized as a Christian I may at times be unhappy, but I always have hope. Even the Psalmist laments.Christianity is not a religion that's designed to make you feel happy all the time. In fact, quite often it does the opposite. As the late 16th century English Preacher William Bridge once said [paraphrase], as Christians we do not seek comfort and in so doing, attain holiness. We seek holiness, are sanctified, and in so doing, find comfort.
Is happiness an integral part of being a Christian? What is the difference between happiness and joy?
Post a Comment
- Back to revelife's Revelife Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in revelife's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)



Recommend



Comments (25)
will be pray for you
I think I reached something...(I don't know if it's a turning point yet because I'm still IN it) about a year back where I just stopped feeling automatically comforted by church. Religion had never been questioned in my life before and now I am coming up with all of these questions, things I am dissatisfied with, and things that I want to talk about, but can't for fear that they're only important points to me and that everyone else will just try to console me that "God loves you." I know that, on some level, I just want a bit more in terms of clear answers. And I am afraid that those just will not be gotten from religion. Church used to be where I went to feel satisfied in my life, and for some reason it really freaks me out that that doesn't do what it used to any more. I hope that whatever has helped you come back into liking Christianity can also affect me. I think Christianity is good, has a lot of good things written in the Bible, lots of good that people are doing in the name of Christianity. (Lots of bad too, but that's the same as anything else- everything can be twisted to fit people's agendas.) I just have questions that are getting in the way of my faith.
I absolutely loved this post! I'm sorry, but most of Revelife is completely cliche, watered down words with empty meanings and gives Atheists a good reason to be an Atheist. Which, might not be Revelife specifically, but Christians as a whole. Nonetheless, I'm really glad this is out there so that people can see that Christians are humans too and there is no happy-switch. Although I'm, personally, much happier than I was before I understood grace and God and the whole package deal. It's not like once you become a Christian, you get this magical force field that protects you from all of the crappy things like homelessness, depression, anxiety, etc. Actually, it might become more frequent given all of the qualities a Christian is supposed to have & do. I think that depression can be easily fixed (without medication, of course- none of that stuff really works long term anyways). It's all in the matter of therapeutic resolutions. NOT like going to a shrink and explaining your relationship with your mother; but with resolving the conflicts that really harbor inside of you and facing your demons so you have the upper hand. While that all may seem very hippy, it works. To me, it would seem spitting-in-the-wind-ish to do otherwise. If you take a pill every day and not fix what's broken, then you'll be taking pills for the rest of your life because life is always going to be depressing/hard. The pills really just numb you up and make you hard to the world. Which probably won't help anyone. Just saying.
I do somewhat disagree with the last few paragraphs. I would be an idiot to look back in my past and say I was happy. Sure, I was a very happy kid growing up, but I never knew anything & was completely oblivious to what this world really is like. As a result of being a dreamer and having a perfect childhood environment, I now have absolutely no idea what I "want to be when I grow up." No clue. I'm not saying that knowing all the heartbreak and cruelty makes me any happier, but at least with knowing it I can flip it around the do my part to start changing it.
Huge difference. Joy is a constant result of being in tune with the Holy Spirit, being able to look at everything in a realistic, hopeful light.
Happiness is brief.
someone just posted a blog on your question:
http://www.revelife.com/739941313/christianity-and-happiness/
i remember this morning and this "eulogy". i sat in my seat for an hour and hummed all the old john denver tunes i could remember. hummed to myself. in my head. so no one else could hear.
when i think of "happy" i think of a feeling that is perhaps fleeting. "joy" makes me think of something deeper...like a sunny spot in my heart where it is never cloudy and never snows. but what do i know? not much.
christians 'think" they are supposed to be happy. maybe we all think we are supposed to be happy. but i love it when i ask someone "how are you today?" and they reply "i feel like crap". good for you. thanks for being real. let's go get coffee and chat about it.
you are a very keen thinker and expresser. you're making me ask myself some hard questions.
I usually feel more depressed in church than anywhere else, because I don't have that perfect life that everyone else seems to, and I don't feel the way everyone else does. I am a Christian, but I am not happy and have very little joy. I do appreciate the smallest joys in life, when they come.
@musicmom60@xanga - I'm in the same boat you are. Honestly, I'm not even going to church right now because it wasn't a healthy environment. And I can tell you this; those people who seem to have that perfect life, don't. I was in one of those families. Everyone thought we were the perfect family and we were very POPULAR. Just before I turned 19 my parents kicked me out of the house for being "rebellious." And for the record I wasn't being rebellious. I was always a good kid and didn't get into trouble. Why my parents decided to lash out at me on so many occasions is beyond me. As you can imagine, this made things impossible at church, the church I grew up in. The church in which I felt safe and comfortable. The church I was involved with on an almost DAILY basis. I was turned away from by my parents and my church family. Very Christian, right? So I left after that. For the past couple years I've been trying to go to other churches but they all seem the same. Fake with "clicks." You meet a few good Christians but feel overwhelmingly out of place. Where are the mature Christians who help develop us and give us the "family" that the Body of Christ is supposed to be? I don't feel disconnected from God, but being out of fellowship with like-minded people, brothers, is difficult and lonely. When will the church realize what's going on and focus on building a strong family? Isn't that what we need? The Body of Christ.......
font-family: "Cambria";
}p.MsoNormal, li.MsoNormal, div.MsoNormal { margin: 0in 0in 0.0001pt; font-size: 12pt; font-family: "Times New Roman"; }div.Section1 { page: Section1; }Okay this may just be ranting but I felt like replying. There
is a big difference in happiness and joy. A Christian can have joy within them
and not be “happy” all the time. Happiness is conditional and temporary. Opening presents on
Christmas will cause one to experience happiness. Happiness depends on
something or someone. The things you are receiving or possibly even the
appreciation of the thoughtfulness towards the people who gave you the gifts,
cause your happiness. Since happiness is conditional it makes sense that it
would be temporary. Happiness lasts until the object of your happiness is
removed or until something else creeps in and steals your attention. Joy, on the other hand, is something that is continuous and
ever increasing. For a Christian the Lord is both the source and object of joy.
Joy is a fruit of the Spirit (Galatians 5:22) and therefore a gift to every
believer. As you grow in faith and your relationship with Christ, you grow in
joy. It is something that we have
in us at all times, even if we are not “feeling happy”. A Christian does not always feel happy. I would argue that
they can be quite the contrary. A Christian laments at their sin, at the sin of
the worldly people that surround them, and in their hardships. A mark of a
Christian includes suffering and hardships. However, what sets us apart from
the world is the way we get through the difficult times. And the joy of Christ, hope in
salvation and knowledge of God’s sovereignty is what makes, for example, a
Christian parent react differently then a non-Christian when they lose their
child. Of course the Christian parents can be devastated in such a situation,
but they have “a sunny spot in [their] heart” as a pervious post stated (which
I would say is really the Holy Spirit in us). And in Josh’s case, and many others out there, that joy can
be masked for a period of time but if you are a true child of God, you will get
through it, with His help and obtain that joy (Jude 1:24). And God works in many ways, like through
people and His word. And that help does not always come from the church, and
you know why? Because truthfully not everyone in the church is a child of God
and even children of God are not perfect. If you rely on people, on the church,
instead of God, you will fail every time. God, unlike people, never
disappoints.
Have you ever read about the life of William Cowper? His struggle with depression was powerful but the hymns born out of his darkest moments were mightier still.
http://www.igracemusic.com/hymnbook/authors/william_cowper.html
@TheyCallMePaulNow@xanga - I completely agree. The Body of Christ is "supposed" to include all of us, and we are called to build each other up. I don't see that happening at most places. The only church I've really felt that at was the one we belonged to before we moved here, 13 years ago. I should have never left that church or moved my children away from that church. I think "the church" still considers many groups or categories as "untouchables" - as in your instance, or single moms, kids of single parents, gays, handicapped, probably lots of others....we don't fit into their mold of "perfect family" mom dad kids. It's unfortunate.
That was a very thought provoking post.
A friend of mine gave me a book called "When I don't desire God." because I too felt like I was not a true Christian b/c i was not filled with the warm fuzzy emotions that come along with being in love with God, and being filled with the spirit. But emotions don't define your faith. Sometimes God gives you those warm feelings, other times you have to lead with your head when your heart feels empty, and eventually God will meet you where you are, and fill you up again.
Life won't always be good, and we won't always be happy, but we know that God never leaves us.
"Depression can very much become an addiction. It may be uncomfortable
and certainly painful, but it’s also attractive as a sedative; it’s
familiar and easily accessible. It takes discipline and work to stay
positive in a world that’s generally chaotic and seemingly random—at
least for a depressive. But it takes almost no work to wallow in
despair—it’s a passive act."
this.
I know what you are dealing with. I deal with it, too. It's hard, every day. But believe me, it won't always be this bad. Maybe moderately sucky more of the time, but it won't be truly horrible forever. Have hope. @needtobreathe22@xanga - I disagree with your take on the necessity of medication. I tried everything, and I mean, EVERYTHING, including sitting down with a shrink, and they all helped a little, but not enough. The medication bought me breathing space. The medication kept things from going haywire while I figured out how I ticked, and what changes in thinking and action I needed to make. The medication made it possible for the other methods to take hold. I am not currently on any now, because I was able to figure out some things and learn what signs to look for when I'm starting the downward spiral, and I know some methods to reverse it now. Every day is still a balancing act, but I'm glad I had that help to get me to where I am now.
Panic attacks can happen any where. And Happiness is ddifferent for everybody.
awesome... thank you for sharing this personal piece.
Thanks for writing this. I suffer not from panic attacks, but from other symptoms of anxiety--especially social, and I sometimes feel a disconnect when I am at church anymore. I appreciate how clearly you've written your thoughts here and they serve as a good example to me and my own future journal entries.
@TheDeepRedCharlie@xanga - It works for different people. I've taken medication for depression & anxiety, but all they really did was numb me up and give me memory loss. I didn't have a good reaction, but it's different for others. I just wouldn't go through the side-effects ever again.
Good blog. Way to step it up a notch.
As someone who has just pulled out of a staggering depression (I lost 4 babies in the last 12 months), I can tell you happiness has nothing to do with my relationship with God. Peace, gratitude and trust define it though.
Have you ever considered that your religion contributes to your anxiety in a negative way? I'm not saying that God doesn't exist or that you shouldn't believe in God, but there is a lot of shit in the Bible that if I believed I would be terrified of the floor collapsing 24/7.
I used to believe it. Nothing was ever good enough. The stuff that didn't make sense would give me headaches. I used to stay awake at night praying for hours trying to get some answers. I spent 7 years terrified that I was going to hell for the time I said fuck you to God when I was 9. I did penance all the time. I still do, actually.
But a great deal of my anxiety was alleviated when I let go of any attachment to the Bible. And it's hard to explain, but think of it as an enlightenment. It was like my head was clouded and I didn't even know it. Then I stopped believing it and suddenly I realized how ridiculous all of it was.
You don't need Christianity to know what it is to be a good person.
@needtobreathe22@xanga - I'm sorry you had such awful side effects! I had some bad ones, too, but not as bad as yours. I know what you mean about feeling numb, though. It's like being in a glass box. You can't quite feel. That was definitely the non-physical side effect I hated the most.
@TheDeepRedCharlie@xanga - Well, thanks. But, I guess sometimes, that indestructiblenumbness is what you need to get on with your life.
I have written an article about my own experience of mental health issues in the church which you may be interested in:
churches, depression and mental illness.