Monday, 22 February 2010
-
Bridging the Gap Between the Church and Millennials
By Justin at BeDeviant
Somebody call Will.I.Am. We need to start bridging the gap.USA Today came out with a shocking-but-not-unexpected article concerning the religious habits of Millennials.
As I said, the results are unsurprising:
- Young adults today are less church-connected than prior generations were when they were in their 20s.
- Millennials are just about as spiritual as their parents and grandparents were at those ages.
- Millennials are significantly more likely than young adults in earlier generations to say they don’t identify with any religious group.
My question isn’t, “Is this true?” (it is), but “What do we do about this?” (Although stubborn, hard-heads in Christendom are no doubt plugging their ears and saying, “LALALALA! If I don’t hear it, it won’t be true!”) Those of us “on the ground” know this to be true. Most people in the know realize there is a significant gap between the Church and Millennials.
Christians have a responsibility to reach out to all people, regardless or race, color, religion …. or age. Millennials, largely, are not connecting with the “product” that we’re pushing out.
I find this problematic.
Also troubling:
Worship attendance is sliding steadily, too: 18% of Millennials say they attend worship nearly every week or more often, vs. 21% of Gen Xers when they were in their 20s and 26% of Boomers at those ages.
At some point, you have to push past the religious language that we like to use to explain this phenomenon away: “The Holy Spirit will draw them back to the Church,” “We just need to pray harder,” “If we keep doing what we do with excellence, we’ll be fine.”
Incorrect.
Millennials have drawn back the covers on the Church and they don’t like what they see. Eesh. At this point, it seems a change–even a drastic change–needs to be made in the North American church’s way of doing ministry.
So instead of dwelling and stewing in this unflattering reality, how do we move forward?
Post a Comment
- Back to revelife's Revelife Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in revelife's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)


Recommend



Comments (33)
keep the Gospel the way it is... purely as simple as it goes... we're all sinners, hell is hot, forever is a long time and the person and work of Jesus is the way out of it...
Millenials though sharp as they may be... they are open to spiritual things... but what they are closed to is absolutes and thus makes them more ignorant than anything and it's the matter of tackling that ignorance... as far as I'm aware of, ignorance leads to apathy which leads to a personal POV that amounts to nothing but spiritual laziness and thus again, results in even more apathy... because there's no solid spiritual foundation to build upon and because of the zeal against that which is objective and absolute, it's no wonder Millenials don't like stability or foundational ideals, cuz they themselves are as to and fro like ocean waves...
Weed out all the hypocrites in the church! I'm not talking about new believers still going through their cleansing, but a lot of the longtime church goers aren't staying true to the faith. We have a lot of people who like to mix politics and culture with Christianity. We also have a lot of people who either blatantly say lies to our youth or twist the word to support their point of view. One good example of this is purity camps which tell our teens sex is bad, when it should be sex is good within the boundaries of marriage.
Stop using Christianity as a form of discipline on our youth is another one. Along with that, stop trying to conform Christianity to the patterns of this country. The typical American lifepath is go to school, then go to college, then get full time job, then get married, then raise a family. That might not be the path God has planned for everybody. I think we need to be able to radically let go of these social norms, even if it means marry as teenagers and grow up sooner, instead of having multiple bf/gfs and stirring up romance before it's time. 100 Years ago, that wasn't so out of the picture. Same with college, God's plan might lead you beyond your church walls to go serve in another country, instead of going to college.
@leadworshipper82 - Wow, to me that seems profoundly true..."they are open to spiritual things... but what they are closed to is absolutes"
...but what is absolute about a mysterious God? If I claim to know something I can only believe by faith...than the truth of that thing is only as deep as my faith. God is the author and finisher of my faith. Its all Him, eh? So how can I judge another's faith...I'd only be judging God Himself.
My experience is that faith is built on a journey. I suspect if the church invited young people to a journey accepting them right where they are...honoring them with their current level of faith...young people would flock to the church. They would view the church as offering something of value...teaching on the life/spiritual journey. Today it seems that many church's judge people who don't fit the cultural standard...follow the 'rules'...or profess faith that is in truth merely fragile. A deep abiding faith I've come to believe is a life time journey, developed in a furnace of doubt, incubated through spiritual discipline. That's my current church's teaching, but I'd not seen that practiced, encouraged, nor even understood in other places in my past...but praise God He is calling those He loves into these ancient ways!
Praise the living God!
@god_stories@xanga - the question is that must be posed is... is the other's faith true?! Just because someone has "faith" it doesn't necessarily mean faith in the One True God. You can faith in a chair that won't crumble underneath your weight... doesn't mean that chair is God... the fact that Millenials don't like such statements as, "Jesus is the only way to heaven." is the absolutes they don't like to hear because it means having a closed mind and a faith based on exclusivity... and in such a generation and age where everyone wants to be all inclusive makes for a rather difficult conversation cuz the people who claim to be open-minded tend to be more close-minded than they let on to be...
the Millenial group needs to simply have the Gospel told to them and to understand that this mysterious God has made Himself known in the person and work of Jesus and when Millenials focus on that... regardless of how savvy they are or how intelligent they exhibit themselves to be... Jesus will have more of a profound impact on them irrespective of their journey and where they are at in their faith... again, just because you're spiritual, doesn't mean you're a Christian...
@leadworshipper82 -
Just because someone has "faith" it doesn't necessarily mean faith in the One True God.
But, in a system that relies upon faith, how can anyone claim absolute certainty about anything?
It takes faith to believe that the Bible is true. It's not a self-evident fact, and most Christians can't even agree amongst themselves 100% of the time.
As a preacher I agree that there is a huge gap right now.
What I see happening (with no real success) is that people are changing what they are reaching out with instead of how they reach out-- this is causing devastating effects. What I mean is that people have begun trying to "change" God, or the Word of God, or what it Says in order to allow them to do whatever they want because they think it will be more popular.
For example; Coca Cola changed its original recipe on April 23rd, 1985 hoping to bring new life into its industry. Unfortunately the plan backfired. Their fans were outraged and hated the new taste.
Now, because Coca Cola was out for success it did not get stubborn on its flawed plan and quickly, after only 79 days it returned to its original recipe (now named Coca Cola Classic) on July 11th, 1985.
The side effect was more successful than the original plan; because they didn't stick to a failing plan their fans were excited by the return of their classic and favorite drink and Coca Cola Classic came back bigger than ever.
My point is that this new idea to "Change" Christianity is a bad idea in the first place. Christs sacrifice was perfect to begin with; his Word is transcendent and flawless. What we were taught in the scriptures does not need to be tweaked or changed; it allows the liberty to reach out using new mediums, but the message is always the same.
Thats my opinion at least.
@Teufels_Hofnarr@xanga - if you observe the empirical evidence concerning the Bible... then it's not a blind faith more so than it is a faith born of reason... the problem with people is that they think or they think that they KNOW that Christianity is this blind faith that one just accepts all willy-nilly... that is not simply the case... it's more along the lines of, "Jesus said this, Jesus did this, Jesus meant this... now that you've observed and reasoned all of what He said, do you now believe Him or not?" That is Christianity... a faith born of reason...
@leadworshipper82 -
But how do you know Jesus was real? Or that everything described in the Bible happened exactly the way it says that it did? There's no proof, it all relies on faith.
Could you share some of the empirical evidence behind the Bible with me? So much of it seems so fantastic and supernatural that it seems hard to call it a faith born from reason.
I don't know how to connect with Millennials. I'm a throwback, I believe in rigid right and wrong, and I'm very intolerant of stupidity.
So the twenty-somethings, the late teens, the whoevers who are stoned/lazy/throwing their lives away make me sick. They've been marketed a message and they're listening to it: the world is crazy and chaotic and you can't do a thing about it.
My Main Point: We have to figure out a way to reach past their cynicality. Young people want emotion. Most churches these days, statistically, are dead and dried up: shrinking in attendance rather than increasing. We have to find a way to make them understand that God is REAL without compromising the Gospel. That's how the emergent groups are coming out.
Young people want sincere emotion and real life principles instead of a Goodwill Gospel handed down.
The question is ... how do we translate this into ministry and outreach? Younger music? More Where You're At preaching? Well ... Idk.
"So instead of dwelling and stewing in this unflattering reality, how do we move forward?"
i think the problem is that, for centuries, Christianity has presented itself as an absolutely 100% provable explanation of reality... usually through stifling and covering up any evidence contrary to that fact. in this era, that's pretty much impossible, yet Christianity as a whole doesn't seem to think so. no one is going to choose a religion unless belief in that religion is useful in some way. i think Christianity is spending too much time trying to prove points and shush anyone speaking against it, and not enough time making itself relevant.
growing up (i am a Millennial, in every way, and proud of it!), Christianity was "right" because of the following reasons:
-other religions had no historical proof
-Christianity had overwhelming historical proof (i remember being told that they had Noah's Ark, a piece of the cross, and John the Baptist's head in museums somewhere... also, that they had located Sodom and Gomorrah, Eden, and the country of origin of the Three Wise Men)
-the Earth was proved to have been made in seven days, roughly 6000 years ago (i never heard of evolution before age 13)... all animals deemed extinct died off because Noah didn't let them on the Ark
-everyone is Christian by default... unless they're evil mass murderers.
i could go on, but i think you get the point. i, and a lot of former Christians i know, just feel flat out lied to. the second i met a decent human being who wasn't Christian, everything was thrown into doubt.
@WritingPassion@xanga -
here's a thought:
"I don't know how to connect with
Millennials. I'm a throwback, I believe in rigid right and wrong, and
I'm very intolerant of stupidity.
So the twenty-somethings, the late
teens, the whoevers who are stoned/lazy/throwing their lives away make
me sick. They've been marketed a message and they're listening to it:
the world is crazy and chaotic and you can't do a thing about it."
stop stereotyping. nothing makes me want to see religion as a whole just end completely more than that opinion.
@Teufels_Hofnarr@xanga - "But how do you know Jesus was real..."
Are you being serious right now?!? Like really?
@leadworshipper82 - "Are you being serious right now?!? Like really?"
Exactly! If one doesn't provide space for another to ask questions, to 'experience' Truth, to feel honored on their journey, than how can one be surprised that the other doesn't engage honestly...or at all.
I don't know you and its likely you're trying to use humor, but my perception of your comment is that you're choosing to not honor @Teufels_Hofnarr@xanga's very rational and reasonable questions. Honest and intimate conversations (and conversations about God are both) require some level of safety. Displaying a lack of respect for another's questions does not establish a safe condition for intimacy...and again conversations about faith and a living God IS an intimate conversation. It touches the deepest desires in a human's heart.
Regarding your earlier response to my comment: Jesus was the most inclusive person I know in all of history...there's nothing about Him that claims exclusivity. 2 Cor 5 "And he died for all, that those who live should no longer live for
themselves but for him who died for them and was raised again."
And if one 'accepts' what one is told as true that's merely a shallow (or perhaps innocent/ignorant is a better description) faith...in my experience (James 1:22-23). It is only through honestly expressing doubts, questions, and perceptions of reality on the life journey is faith built. Again just my own experience, but feedback I hear from millennials sound familiar to my experience (as a late baby boomer).
Praise the living God!
@leadworshipper82 -
Well, yes. How do you know Jesus was real and that everything the Bible says about Him is true?
I've never met someone who was born from a virgin. Science tells me that's impossible. So, how can you be certain about Jesus being different?
@god_stories@xanga -
Thank you! I was worried he was going to bite my head off!
@Teufels_Hofnarr@xanga - Your welcome!
...and my $.02 on Biblical stories...they are wildly crazy...totally ridiculous! I mean a man swallowed by a fish for 3 days and lives, baby boy born of a virgin, people raised from the dead...that's all over-the-top weird. Like why would anyone even think up those kind of stories...let alone believe them as true...I am so with you on all that!
But then I oddly (and suddenly) have weird supernatural things happen to me...like a woman friend of mine spontaneously (and very oddly) prays with another friend to meet a 'powerful woman of God', since she doesn't see a place for powerful women in the church...and within two hours meets a woman who says that God used her to raise someone from the dead (did it actually happen? You can read how I think about that here). I have a very 'random' day dream driving my pick-up...then see it come to pass 'exactly' as I envisioned it in my day dream. My nephew is taken ill and put in the hospital for tests...I get a word from God that gives my sister strength to walk through the crisis of her son's diagnosis of leukemia. Or after a few years of taking bigger and bigger risks in faith I have enough faith to actually pray for physical healing for some people I'd just met...and people are healed!
So I begin to wonder if those crazy stories in the Bible might be true...but its only after walking a journey...led (I now believe) by a living God! I only had life experience to judge the truth of the Bible (parts I could kinda believe, but other parts no way, too weird). Now with more (and different) life experience I believe more as true (but still not all of it...honestly).
So how do I think about faith? I now give myself permission to question my beliefs, ask what are my deepest desires, and then pursue them! I've found joy, experiences of Truth (as relational...not objective), and amazing weird supernatural experiences.
I'm praying right now for you to experience the same!!
@Teufels_Hofnarr@xanga - dude... to say how can you say Jesus was real... i'll answer that correctly if you can tell me how George Washington was real... can you? I suppose it takes faith to believe George Washington was real too right?
@god_stories@xanga - ok... when one suggests that it takes faith to believe in a historic person that HISTORY has documented... that's really just... ignornat and not rational... seriously dude... it's not that hard... you and I both know historica facts are the basis for what come to grips with...
If I were to doubt you that George Washington wasn't the first president... what would you say to me?
@leadworshipper82 - that's not a very accurate comparison for a number of reasons...
- George Washington lived during a period where the written word was far more prevalent. he has far more contemporary works that mention him than Jesus ever did.
- the main sources to mention Jesus outside of the Bible are Josephus, Tacitus, Pliny, and Suetonius. only Josephus calls him Jesus... the rest refer to him as the Christ, which is a title (not a name). the George Washington equivalent of this would be if every non-propaganda source but one just mentioned some guy called "The General," and how he led a bunch of Americans to revolt.
- out of the aforementioned sources, Josephus is the earliest... in 93 AD. in contrast, we have thousands of papers written by Washington, not just about him.
- the Gospels are religious texts first, and historical texts second. they were written with a particular intent: to spread a message. the intent was not to be 100% accurate. and if you believe that early Christians wouldn't have fudged some facts to preserve their beliefs, i think that takes a lot more faith than believing in any god.
by your logic, you should probably be Muslim... Muhammad has far more historical references supporting his existence than Jesus ever did, so of course the theological claims surrounding him are more factual...right?
@too_pretty_to_die@xanga -
Bravo!
@leadworshipper82 -
George Washington's actions aren't supernatural, Jesus' were. There aren't any historical facts that back up the story of Jesus, just religious texts that have an interest in promoting him as the son of god.
@Teufels_Hofnarr@xanga - thanks. i just get so confused when Christians (or any theists, really) try to present faith as something derived from reason. one, the underlying (and perhaps, unintentional) message is that if faith is reasonable, a lack of faith is unreasonable. i'm not about to join a group of people who seem to think that those without faith are somehow less intelligent, or "just don't get it." as a rather famous atheist once said, the burden of argument lies with them. if i went around believing i could fly, and then asked someone to prove to me that i couldn't... it's completely illogical. the burden of proof would lie with me to show that i can fly to begin with.
two, i can't see why they'd want faith to be on the same level as other "provable" sciences, anyway. it'd never stand up under the same scrutiny, and it's not really supposed to. if it was a reasonable conclusion, the same way we can conclude that gravity exists, then it wouldn't be faith. and isn't that what they need to get into Heaven... faith, as opposed to knowledge?
@too_pretty_to_die@xanga -
You're preaching to the choir, pun intended!
Sent you a friend request.
@Teufels_Hofnarr@xanga - GW was a historic figure... that is what your idea or your notion was about... Jesus was just as a historic figure...
@too_pretty_to_die@xanga - then u need to read up... i suggest Josephus, Plimey the Great who all documented the reality of the Christian faith tied TO Jesus...
@leadworshipper82 -
"then u need to read up... i suggest
Josephus, Plimey the Great who all documented the reality of the
Christian faith tied TO Jesus..."
documentation of people believing something =/= proof that the aforementioned something exists.
@leadworshipper82 - "ok... when one suggests that it takes faith
to believe in a historic person that HISTORY has documented... that's
really just..."
So this conversation so succinctly reveals to my mind the divide between many churches and millennials. Its not clear to me that @Teufels_Hofnarr@xanga is asking if Jesus was a real historical figure. Sure he might have even used those words, but it seems to me there's a meta conversation going on...beneath the obvious (I sense the same in other's comments here). As I said before exploring faith is a deep, mysterious, and intimate journey. If we're older than 12 years old than our past is likely fraught with pain and suffering...and it can be scary and difficult to navigate relationship with a living God.
So to cut short the conversation with Bible verses, trite sayings, superior cultural attitude, advice, rational arguements or anything other than a humble attitude that can lead to a real personal relationship between honest humans is not helpful.
Praying a prayer of salvation isn't a key to the executive boys room...and the good life. Life is a journey...likely a long journey...and the abundant life that Jesus offers (in my experience) comes from relationship (with Him and with others), right? Life is merely a string of moments...sometimes life feels abundant and sometimes not...whether you're a follower of Jesus or not. Having honest conversation is key to relationship...and honest conversation about our struggles, doubts, confusion, joy, and what we think we know...can only be helpful for the other...and ourselves!!
God is a mystery and anyone who claims to know 'objective truth' about Him is likely holding tightly to a pretty small 'image' of who God is...in fact I sense everyone can only know a very small image God...He is way more than we can imagine...so the Bible says (and my experience confirms)!
Sorry for the long comment...praise the living God!
I think that we should stop and pray. Only the spirit can give us the answers for church renewal. There are so many books about it....so many diagnoses..but I'm certain that the Spirit holds the key.
Before Jesus ascended into heaven he told his disciples, that the Holy Spirit would come to them. What did the disciples do next? They prayed together constantly. They waited on the Lord and prayed. The Spirit did eventually come. (Acts 1-2). The Spirit shaped the new ecclesia.
There definitely needs to be change, however, it must be Spirit led. I think that we forget about prayer waaaay too much. But also, people need to be open to what the Spirit is saying...it might change everything.