Friday, 04 December 2009

  • Skip the Lottery: Go to This Church!

    The economic crisis has put the financial health of many people, businesses and organizations in jeopardy. While many tighten their belts, lay off employees or stage fundraisers to stay in business, one church in Illinois is doing something unthinkable: giving away money.

    According to a recent article in the Chicago Tribune, the Rev. Dan Willis of the Lighthouse Church of All Nations in Alsip, Illinois, is giving away $1000 every Sunday service as part of his “focus on helping his congregation pay bills and begin a debt-free life.” He doesn't stop there; a shredder was installed in the church where members can shred their credit cards. The article continues:

    He talks about budgeting, tackling past-due bills and saving. He encourages the prize winners to use the money to pay down their bills, rather than splurge on new items. One Sunday, he gave away 15 savings accounts with $25 already in them. And he had bank representatives at the service so church members could set up accounts.

    Willis was inspired to focus on debt and finances when he realized people's faith is high when their debt is low. Helping his congregation lower their debt will, by his logic, increase their faith, and as a pastor, it is his priority to increase the faith of his church.

    The connection between debt and faith is not the only connection that can be made in this situation, though. The free money giveaways are also connected to an increase in attendance of about 1,000 people since the giveaways began. This is no surprise to Willis, who, according to the article, “concedes the cash prize is a gimmick to fill the pews. But he’s unapologetic about the plan, because it’s working.”

    Trying to better the lives of his congregation is an honorable and respectable thing for a pastor to do, but giving away money as a gimmick to fill emptying seats – and conceding that this is so – might be somewhat concerning. Motivations can sometimes be just as important as results, and motivations can be the difference between a display of generosity and a simple gimmick.

    Regardless of the intentions, the congregation is receiving a vital message, one that many people need to hear during this time of financial struggle: get out of debt, spend wisely, and give to others.

    Do you think the giveaway amounts to a gimmick or is a display of generosity? Can it be both? Do you think the people who are showing up will stay even after the giveaway is over?

Comments (11)

  • LoBornlyte@xanga

    Gimmick is lie.  Generosity is charity.


    Let's see. Lie... Truth...


    Somebody needs to be clubbed like a baby seal.


  • ProDigit

    I got saved because of a beautiful girl in youth, and because of the youth's love and friendship!
    That's what drew me. It certainly wasn't because I had all my priorities right in loving God first!

  • TheGreatBout@xanga

    I wonder if they will use Dave Ramsey's stuff...

    @ProDigit - I stayed for the hotties too. Then I met Jesus and he was like "Dude... come on." We've been friends since.

  • HollowTendencies@xanga
  • melloyello

    I don't think people should be given a prize for going to church. But I do believe we should teach how to spend wisely. It is called stewardship. Some people have never had a bank account or learned how to manage one. Maybe if the program had something where the people involved helped someone else down the road. Habitat for Humanity does that. If you get a house you have to put in a certain number of hours of helping building homes. 

  • ShimmerBodyCream@xanga
  • a_single_raindrop@xanga

    @melloyello - I agree. I think it will call people to the church for the wrong reasons ... instead of having a lottery every Sunday service, maybe they should give the money to families in the church who really need it.

  • anonymous
  • BlehhItsTu@xanga

    So somebody who's more fortunate has more "faith" than someone less fortunate might.. Hmm.. True, but should faith even derive from such things?


    Out of selfishness, I'd love to go to that church

  • momzmybiz@xanga

     I think that it is a display of generosity. If his church membership decreases those members joined the church for the wrong reason, which happens all the time.

  • tracezilla@lovelyish

    I think it can be both. I can see why some people might be outraged at something like this. But, I don't think the pastor is trying to JUST fill pews. The point of filling the pews means that more people will hear his messages. He has two. The one that was mostly talked about here, which was the help those get out of debt (to increase faith) and also the message of God.

    To him, I'm sure, the more people that come to the church to hear God's message, the more people who might be swayed to actually believe or those who already do might be swayed to increase their faith. As a pastor, that should be what is actually important. Not that the new people in the pews are simply there, but the fact that he has a chance to reach more people than usual with the message of God and to increase the faith of those who already believe.

    To him, both of these would be good for the congregation (not just the church and not just him), because the whole point is to save people and keep them saved.

    Of course there will be people who stop coming (probably a lot of the people who started to come just for the cash prizes) when the prizes stop being given out. But, to him, I'm sure, there is a good chance that there will be a lot of people who choose to keep coming. And even if it is only one or two people out of that huge increase that end up staying, if he is a true pastor then it will have still been worth it.

    But, I know that it looks more like his only purpose is really just to fill his pews to make himself and his church look better. Still, if he's a true pastor and truly believes in the faith he preaches, then that should not be what it is truly about.

    Either way, people who need the help are being helped. I'm not religious, so to me as long as people are being helped I'm happy. I'm not worried about the pastor's motives.

  • Choose Identity

  • Give eProps (?)

About the Author

Who recommended?