Thursday, 15 October 2009
-
Mapping Sin in the U.S.
by Goose at Faith and GeekeryIt’s a unique feature of our technological age that we are now able to pinpoint, measure, and graph nearly every significant trend we experience…and many insignificant ones as well. You want to know how many gum chewers there are nationwide and what brand they’re chomping on? Okay. How about the average life expectancy of an enemy soldier in a Chuck Norris film? Wonder no more. But never before has there been a thorough examination of sin – which ones are being committed where and with what frequency. Now you may go ahead and check that box as well.Geography gurus at Kansas State University unveiled a new study this spring that took a closer look at the Seven Deadly Sins. You remember those guys? Greed, Envy, Sloth, Wrath, Lust, Pride, and Gluttony. Using a formula we’ll explicate further in just a moment, these Kansan creatures were able to pinpoint which areas of these United States are the worst offenders in each area and which locales don’t struggle. Some humorous, remarkable, maybe even convicting stuff here. (For a more in-depth look at the maps below, check out this report.)
According to Kansas State University, if you are from the Eastern Seaboard of South Carolina and Georgia, you are probably one angry individual. Along with Floridians, the study pegged these folks as the most likely to deal with wrath. They used the number of violent crimes per capita in that determination. Not sure if that has anything to do with lingering angst over Shermann’s March to the Sea? Bad seafood? Unfortunately, the Bible Belt’s sin center issues don’t cease with wrath. They are also nation-leaders in lust and envy (as calculated by number of reported STD cases and total number of thefts per capita, respectively). Yikes.
Envy and Lust
Sloth! You just never hear that word anymore! This sin is all over the place. The Kansans used a formula to measure it that took into account the average expenditure per capita on arts and entertainment. So these people do artsy things too often – the rogues. Although this is scattered all over the nation, two epicenters of sloth are Washington D.C. and (oddly enough) Western Montana! People are aware that congresspersons (I’m feeling politically correct today) are prone to wasting money. What folks may not realize, however, is that Western Montana has been almost entirely repopulated with wealthy tree huggers from California. They need to be entertained.
Meanwhile, greed (computed by average income compared to those living below poverty line) dwells most commonly in California (see preceding paragraph) and the great conurbation stretching from Northern Virginia to Massachusetts. This would seem to further indicate various notions (held by this author) that people from the country are at a distinct aesthetic and enjoyment advantage over their urban-jungle dwelling compatriots.
While Texas bears a great deal of affection for big oil, the KState research indicates that the other factor looming large in the state is big people. Central Texas is the nation’s great hub of gluttony. Kentucky and Virginia also make appearances. That statistic was derived from the number of fast food restaurants per capita. Incidentally, I saw recently an interactive map you could use to determine your current distance from a McDonalds wherever you happened to be at present. Ba-da-ba-da-baaaa…Lastly, there’s pride, which these Kansas folk figured was at the root of every other sin. Thus the map for pride is an aggregate of all the other maps. If your curiosity is piqued, you can head over to Wired and check it out.
In our post-post modern society it’s strange to even read the word ’sin’ this much. Even in Christian media outlets, the trend is toward other, more gentle, less harsh terms to express the concept of doing wrong. As odd and bizarre as this study is – any potential reminder that God is control, has a plan for humanity and sets out standards of right and wrong might just be a good thing.
And the average life expectancy of an enemy combatant in a Chuck Norris film is 4 seconds.
Post a Comment
- Back to revelife's Revelife Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in revelife's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)
















Comments (29)
While I question the measurements used, I am amused by the bible belts overall standings.
Well...I'm glad to be in Pittsburgh instead of Philly right now, I guess?
Florida is apparently all sorts of devilish. I should move back to the wholesome midwest!
The Bible Belt is overall more ~sinful~ you say? Well, color me shocked. [/sarcasm]
Not quite sure how one would measure some of these sins though, but I'm sure that a region that prides itself on supposedly being holier-than-thou is actually the most sinful of all.
Funny how the Bible Belt has the most "sin"...
Not exactly discussed here, but church attendance shares quite a stunningly close correlation with murder rates. I love it.
Seven deadly sins = not in the Bible.
When God gets mad at people, it's because they're not taking care of the poor, not because they're sleeping around. (Ezekiel 16:49)
Does that mean that the seven deadly sins aren't bad? No, absolutely not. But we must first remember why they are bad, and it is because they breed systemic problems that are deeply opposed to they way of the Kingdom.
With this in mind, maybe they should map out places that most closely resemble the Kingdom.
Their choices of measure are pretty lame (sloth was the worst)
Sounds pretty good besides lust. STD rate does not equal lust, that could just mean that people are too stupid to use condoms or make sure their partner is clean first.
Everyone everywhere is sinful. This is an interesting look at sins that society actually records, like murder, but everyone has a sin nature. There may be more institutionalized sin in some areas, but people are the same everywhere in their hearts. I highly doubt a God's-eye view of the map would show very many differences in sinfulness from state to state.
You can be born with an STD, and that's reported, too...
@foxes_have_holes@xanga - Actually, they are in the Bible. (I'm not saying the study interpreted them correctly.) This is where they come from:
Proverbs 6:16-19 There are six things the LORD hates,
seven that are detestable to him:
17 haughty eyes,
a lying tongue,
hands that shed innocent blood,
18 a heart that devises wicked schemes,
feet that are quick to rush into evil,
19 a false witness who pours out lies
and a man who stirs up dissension among brothers.
@walkintotheseaaa@xanga - Actually, they are in the Bible. Check out my response to foxes_have_holes. They're in Proverbs 6:16-19
@Pickwick12@xanga - first of all, the term "seven deadly sins" is not in the bible, and the ones you listed are also not the same as the ones considered the "seven deadly sins," and a couple of those are the same.
Too bad that this study can't keep track of people's thoughts, that's where most sins start anyway...
@foxes_have_holes@xanga - I'm not a Biblical scholar, so don't take what I say as fact, but I believe the passage in Proverbs is at least in part the basis for the seven deadly sins. They are not actually listed in the Bible as the list exists today, though I believe they are the seven most commonly discussed sins in the Bible. I can't remember from my religion classes whether it was an early monk or a pope who decided upon which sins were the worst, but I think that's where the origin comes from. I'm probably just as accurate as Wikipedia, but this is just what I remember from Catholic school.
Go Iowa! Woot!
Oh my gosh! I totally know these guys and they're my neighbors. They started this study just because they thought it would be hilarious, but now everyone's made a big deal out of it. The one who led the study, Tom Vought, is dating one of my good friends. We go out on double dates. They're a fun bunch.
Funny...and fun! But not sure I'm getting your final point...sin isn't about God is it? My take is that sin is more about 'the law' or moral standards...both of which are unhelpful to having a good time (aka the abundant life, Jesus promised), eh?
A bit off topic, sorry, totally appreciate your article...thanks for posting!
@modernmelody - it seems more like to me that there is only one deadly sin, and it is selfishness. is this not the root of all of the seven deadly sins?
....lol
You've got to be kidding me.
Having worked on Wall Street, my money would have been on NYC for greed, gluttony, and lust.
Sometime in the late 80s or early 90s I read a statistic that was hugely disturbing. The U.S. led the world one year with over 11,000 murders. Coming in second was Great Britain with 13. That's not a typo. It's the number that follows twelve. Some "patriotic" Americans, not wanting to face the music of those statistics claimed it was because murders are underreported in Great Britain, and in the other countries with even lower body counts. It would take a lot of people not caring that a loved one showed up in the morgue to account for that much underreporting. I guess we could look at this in a positive light. It means job security for our men and women in police uniforms.
In any case, the statistics mentioned in this blog are interesting.
@TheSutraDude@xanga - good statistics, but it's better to deal with ratios than just overall numbers. America's ratio of murders to people is still really high, but it is easier to compensate for population differences.
Personally, I think the entire map should just be dark red. If we honestly think we can accurately measure sin by human standards and not God's... well, that just seems like a bad idea.
@foxes_have_holes@xanga - While I agree they are not specifically stated in the Bible, neither is "omniscient" or "Trinity" written in the Bible, yet those two claims of God are not really in dispute between those in God's Church. It's a case of the thing/word fallacy. Just because it's not stated, doesn't mean it's not there.
I would challenge you to find a better classification scheme for sin, which is why I believe the "7 deadly sins" has remained prevalent. If you examine the 10 commandments, you'll find most.
Greed, Envy, Sloth, Wrath, Lust, Pride, and Gluttony
Coveting ~ Envy
Murder ~ Wrath
Stealing ~ Greed
Adultery ~ Lust
Honoring the Sabbath ~ Sloth (in the other direction, e.g. never resting)
1 God, No idols, Respencting God's Name, and Honoring Parents ~ Pride
Gluttony is the only one I cannot make a good claim for; however, perhaps one could retrieve that from the Israelites attempting to harvest more than 1 day of mana in the desert.
As for selfishness, I'd say that could be a combination of pride and greed.
If I had to choose only one sin, I'd say it should all be lumped under idolatry -- setting others things up in your heart above God, be it self, other people, or other things/gods.
So while it's not explicitly stated, as you said, that doesn't mean the concept's not there, and I'd say pretty much anything one could dub as "sin" could be found within those 7 categories. It's about the best classification system we have.
As to how helpful having the classification system is, though... that's also still up for debate.
God bless,
~Scott
@gelatinemonkey@xanga - greed- putting yourself above others by hording wealth
envy- putting yourself above others by wanting what they have for yourself
sloth- putting yourself above others by not doing anything for anyone
wrath- putting yourself above others by becoming angry, a form of power used on others
lust- putting yourself above others by desiring their bodies for your own use
pride- putting yourself above others by thinking of yourself in a better way than others
gluttony- putting yourself above others by eating alot while others starve
it all comes back to the selfishness