Tuesday, 13 October 2009
-
The Music Venue: Where the Sacred Meets the Secular
My first post as a Revelife intern was about the separation of “secular” and “sacred” in terms of music. This is a subject that is dear to my heart, having been involved with the music industry in many different formats for the last 12 years. Most recently, I was the director of public relations for a music venue called The Capitol. Our mission was to be a safe place for the youth of our area to hang out and encounter Christian community, and we drew a lot of our inspiration from the acclaimed Christian-run music venue Rocketown, in Nashville, Tennessee. One aspect Rocketown and The Capitol have in common is that, despite being Christian-owned and operated, both book a mix of christian and secular acts. While The Capitol was always very open about this fact, those who frequent Rocketown or support it seem to be less informed about this situation. An upcoming concert, featuring a lineup of secular—possibly anti-Christian—hardcore bands, is causing quite a controversy, leading some to question the venue's motives.
Rocketown was opened in 1994 by Michael W. Smith. According to its website, its mission is to share “Christ’s love with youth through creative programs and mentoring relationships that are culturally relevant and eternally significant.” There are a great number of resources at the disposal of Rocketown's staff, including a skatepark, music venue, and cafe. Besides holding concerts, the venue also has after school classes to teach guitar lessons, photography, dance, and graphic design, among other things. There's even something they call Skate Church, a ministry to the skater crowd.
While all of these outreach programs sound like they match up with Rocketown's mission statement, many think that the upcoming concert, which features the bands Black Dahlia Murder and Skeletonwitch, is counterintuitive to their ministry goals. A recent article on Gospel Soundcheck, a blog on Beliefnet, explains why some are concerned this show might defeat the purpose of the venue:
It seems to be quite a contradiction in mission for Rocketown, to be asking kids to come to hear about Christ, and then giving them a line up of bands who hate Christians. Especially when the Rocketown website is full of references to ministry and Christ. It can send a mixed message that the club endorses the acts that perform there.
The article goes on to say that, although the executive director was unavailable for comment, an employee said that “the club cautions parents to make sure they research the bands their kids are coming to see since not everyone on the bill is a Christian act.”
I can understand where the staff at Rocketown is coming from. At The Capitol, we booked a wide variety of bands, but hardcore shows were the ones that always did the best. Our town, in central Florida, is the hometown of Seventh Star, a widely popular Christian hardcore band on Facedown Records. Several other hardcore bands were birthed in our backyards, so I can relate to the desire to book artists that will attract audiences, especially those who need the love of Christ.
The outlook Rocketown has on ministry is similar to the one The Capitol had. On the Rocketown website, this is outlined in four easy steps; the first two are as follows:
Attraction – In the beginning, there is an attraction. Young people come to Rocketown for it’s great music venue, skatepark, coffee bar and programs.
Building Relationships – Once they are here, attendees find people who accept them as they are. Staff, volunteers and peers have created an inviting community.
In this case, the attraction happens to be a hardcore show, and it's not just any hardcore show—some worry it is a satanist hardcore show. I'll admit: The Capitol never, as far as I know, booked a show entirely of satanist acts, but I can imagine we would have if we felt we had the resources available to meet those in attendance and build relationships with the people in attendance. That's what Rocketown has going for itself; it has the resources few Christian ministries have. It has a large staff, a lot of support, and plenty of reasons for those in attendance, regardless of their beliefs, to return.
I understand the concerns of those who object to this event. After all, we are called to go and make disciples, and attracting a large, possibly anti-Christian crowd doesn't seem, at least at face value, like it would do much in the way of making disciples. There is a chance, though, that the venue will succeed in reaching someone, maybe many people, by inviting this group inside its doors, and I don't think it's our place to judge them for trying to reach the lost by any means necessary. Wasn't Christ the one who hung out with prostitutes and tax collectors? As long as the venue maintains its Christian ideals and doesn't change its mission to meet the masses, I think maybe they have the right idea at heart.
Only time will tell whether or not Rocketown is able to reach out by booking secular and possibly anti-Christian bands. As long as the venue makes it clear that they do not endorse the message of these bands and offers those in attendance the opportunity to experience Christian community, they could prove to be very successful at reaching out to a vast secular audience.
Do you think openly Christian music venues should book openly anti-Christian bands?
Post a Comment
- Back to revelife's Revelife Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in revelife's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)



True
Premium












Comments (9)
Yes, The Forum in Los Angeles still has Lamb of God banned >.> I had to go all they way down to San Diego to see them with Metallica. It would be kind of funny to see Dimmu Borgir, Cradle of Filth or Behemoth at a Christian Venue.
Just out of curiosity, does anyone else feel like Christian Hardcore is disproportionately more popular within its Christian music scene (as far as percentages in comparison with the entire Christian music scene) than is true with the secular hardcore/metal scene?
The people in the bands are worth trying to reach, too. Who knows, maybe they come and play a show for Christian kids and they're the ones affected by what happens that night.
Plus, to say that people in a Satanic-oriented band are going to treat the audience or the venue badly is just stupid. Christians in a band can do just as much damage to their fans or to a building, and nobody ever cautions kids about that.
My two cents: P.O.D. opened for Korn. As a result of this, their guitar player became a Christian.
I'm not saying it's necessarily a good idea; I just wanted to throw this point out there.
Yeah, I think so
I get pretty tired of seeing, "Wasn't Christ the one who hung out with prostitutes and tax collectors?" to explain something like this. I don't recall him hanging out with Satan worshipers, or putting someone who was demon-possessed in the company of others. I'm very disappointed in Rocketown. It's worldly compromising to be doing this and saying that you're doing it to make disciples.
I have a lot of experience working with youth, specifically how music changes and shapes their attitudes and behaviors. I've grown up around it my whole life, and I studied its effects in college. Be sure this WILL NOT have a positive effect. Even if Rocketown can say someone got saved at this event, they did a hell of a lot of damage to a lot more people in the process. Literally.
@thecommonfate@xanga - Yes that is odd. It's probably due to greatness of As I Lay Dying and the lack of good "Christian" music. Also because it is seen as "rebellious" which can be appealing to those looking for something somewhat rebellious but still "Christian"
gabrielpeter...sure wish you would chime in over at beliefnet's gospel soundcheck. The guy who brought this to light over there is being verbally battered for his stance. It seems most people think this is just swell and that those who oppose it are closed-minded. Anyway...here's something to add to the mix, from neufutur.com:
“On the behalf of my mates in The Black Dahlia Murder, we are f*cking pumped to hit the road with Skeletonwitch, Toxic Holocaust, and Trap Them. We have forged this alliance in the name of Satan, hand picking the best bands possible to bring you the most stage dive worthy tour of the fall. Circle up!” comments vocalist Trevor Strnad.
@concerned parent - I appreciate you. If you would, check out my blog tomorrow (Wednesday). I'll have this exact issue posted, and you can redirect people there. It's www.xanga.com/gabrielpeter.