Thursday, 08 October 2009

  • Is Jazzing-Up Youth Group Worth the Price?

    My high school youth group experience was anything but visually inspiring. The youth room was small but sufficient, with plain white walls and grey carpet. There was no stage or even a backdrop; the band played on the floor, and if you think there was an awesome sound system in that place, think again. We had no colored lights or fog machines, but we did cover the windows with black trash bags to add some ambiance. The words to the worship songs were not displayed on some LCD TV or a high-definition projector but instead an overhead projector, the kind you might have seen in elementary school.

    I don't envy youth ministers today. A great deal of time and effort must go toward getting kids away from the distractions of their everyday lives. There are so many things to compete with for the attention of today's youth, from the typical video games and TV to, more recently, the internet and even phones. With all of these interactive and multi-media distractions in the lives of kids, it's hard to imagine how youth ministers manage to juggle it all.

    There is help for some; companies and websites exist that offer materials for youth groups and ministers. Some of them offer a massive amount of resources and visual aids, but they can be pretty expensive! One such company, Interlinc, has a membership-based program called Youth Leaders Only (YLO) that ships out boxes of resources four times a year. The plan, which costs in the hundreds of dollars each year, offers a wide assortment of materials, from CDs and music videos to books of interviews and hundreds of Bible studies. It even offers two different “flavors” of YLO. “Hot” features progressive, alternative music while “mild” contains music from pop and acoustic artists.

    If that is a bit too pricey, there is also Youth Music Vault (YMV), which costs significantly less but also offers less materials. Instead of providing music and Bible studies for several artists, YMV selects one artist every two months and creates messages and materials focusing on just that one artist. To make it even more cost effective, the membership is all online; there are no shipping fees to pay, as members simply log in and download the materials. The selection of artists is limited, though, and youth ministers can't opt for a different plan if the music is too hard or too soft for the youth group's membership.

    YLO and YMV both offer great services, but the quality and quantity of what ministers can get their hands on depends a great deal on how much they're willing to spend, at least when it comes to these membership programs. For small youth groups, like the one I was a part of when I was in high school, these sort of plans are simply not affordable. What can the youth ministers of these groups do to compete with the ones that can afford these materials?

    Maybe, instead of trying to jazz-up youth group and make it prettier to look at, youth ministers should start by being more involved in the lives of the youth to whom they minister. Instead of spending money on fancy videos, inviting some of the youth to the church to make the videos themselves can make the kids feel more involved and important and costs a lot less! Instead of introducing the group to musicians and then handing out pre-made Bible studies about these artists, pastors could instead look to the music their groups are already listening to, read the lyrics and research the artists, and then create Bible studies of their own that are more meaningful to their own groups. Inviting kids over to hang out at the church, play video games and eat pizza worked much better for my youth group than any music video ever could.

    In the end, I don't think it's how the church looks that makes it more relevant; it's how the church acts and becomes involved in the world around it. Youth groups can show all the flashy videos and hip music they want, but if youth ministers don't become involved in their groups lives and encourage them to be involved in their communities, I don't think they'll get any better turn out.

    What are some of your own youth group experiences, good and bad? What are some other ways that youth ministers and youth groups can make their messages relevant to kids today?

Comments (15)

  • MusicologyNut85@xanga

    It sounds like the YMV is just a marketing gag for "Christian artists." I won't play ball with most any of them. Any musician who wants to call themselves "christian" and copyright their stuff so that a church has to have a CCLI license or somesuch to play/perform their music in a service needs to really think long and hard about what they are doing with their art.

  • modernmelody

    @MusicologyNut85@xanga - You're right.  YMV is actually owned by Warner Bros., which makes me think that this is nothing more than a ploy to get kids to listen to Warner Bros. artists.  I could be wrong about their motives, but it's not hard to make the assumption. 

  • leadworshipper82

    i think it's necessary to employ technology and stuff in order to present the message of the Gospel... kids need Jesus just as much and if through visual artistry and musical excellence will bolster the message, not that Jesus needs help or that w/o it, the Gospel can't do it's work... but there is a contextualization to it and w/ kids living in today's quick paced, almost ADD type environments, to utilize things today to allow for the grasp of the Gospel is almost a need commodity...

  • CyanideNGunpowder@xanga

    I think YGs should stop trying to make themselves appear to relate to kids and actually try to relate to them for real.

  • subSacred@xanga

    This may make me sound like an old fart, but God's Word is powerful and sharper than any two edged sword. We should be contemporary and innovative in how we use it and present it, but if kids need to be wooed to God's Word with expensive shiny toys, they are just not gonna be truly interested in God's Word, and their faith will not be firmly rooted.

  • TheGreatBout@xanga

    Youth groups are overrated. Discipleship is underrated. Teens don't need flashy presentations as much as intimate mentorship. Though, it's not really an either/or. You can have both. The latter should definitely be rich in presence though.

    Music was in the background of my youth experience. We went to a concert here and there and we played music or watched a video every week (usually when entering and leaving service) but that's it. The kids made the call on the music though so it felt more like jammin with friends than being advertised to.

  • Red_Apocalypse_Horse@xanga

    Youths are not dumb. They see through the flashiness. Youths need to feel accepted, loved and mentored. The flashiness might attract them in the first place, but what will get them to stay is genuine fellowship and mentoring.

  • MusicologyNut85@xanga

    @modernmelody - My mother works with a production manager for a rather large church, and she often tried to get me involved in the "Contemporary Christian Music" scene (she loathes what I do with early music) she would introduce me to alot of people; and... from my experience in being around them and seeing the way they work (not the musicians themselves, but the people behind them: agents and producers and managers and so on) they strike me as being more for-profit, greedy, and cutthroat than their "secular" counterparts.

    From what I have seen and dealt with, the Contem. Christian genre is more bloodthirsty than regular pop. It's a little sad and actually really did alot to shape my views on copyrights and performance rights. I've seen those people come down harder on Churchs than the MPA, ASCAP, and RIAA does on people who "pirate" music. Seriously, what possible reason could a Christian musican have for threatening legal action against a Church because that Church's band performed "his" song without paying royalties?

  • modernmelody

    @MusicologyNut85@xanga - As someone who helped run a music venue for two years, I know exactly the kind of things you're talking about.  Some of the most surprising experiences I had involved the expectation that the Christian musicians would treat the venue and its employees and attendees better than the "secular" bands.  While this did happen a lot of the time, I was surprised just how many times the Christian bands had bigger ego problems.  That isn't to say that all Christian bands have ego problems; it just made me change my outlook on things, having had a few negative experiences from some bands I had expected would be much more considerate.

  • subSacred@xanga
  • Reiskytl_rules@xanga

    Flashy does not always equal shallow any more than low-key always means a sincere expression of faith. While I'm not familiar with the resources described here, I know that it is tough to develop material for youth group and subscribing to online resources can be very helpful rather than having to reinvent the wheel every time.  I think it's great to come up with creative ways to engage students, whether the local workers or someone else came up with the idea.  The best way to stay relevant is to stay in close contact with the students, hear what they're really dealing with rather than what adults assume they're dealing with, and then help the students develop a Biblical response to the challenges they face. 

  • Pass_the_Aura@xanga

    In my experience, youth ministries in general spend too much time on making their message relevant and not enough time on having a message.

  • EccentricSiren@xanga

    When I was a teen, I really don't think I would have been all that impressed by a big, flashy youth room. I went to a Christian school and I remember feeling like Christianity was being treated like just another product to market.  Like, "how can we make our church look better/seem cooler so that more people will show up?" I hated that.  Still do.  I figured, so much other stuff in this world is just a marketing ploy, so why would I want to go for a religion that felt like one, too?  I think it's almost an insult to teenagers to think that they will show up at youth group if you just have the right electronics and color scheme.  If they want to show up, they'll show up because they want to (or because their parents make them go), not because you painted the room the right color.  Teens, like most people, do things because it seems appealing to them, not because someone kept trying to pretend to know what their demographic wants and trying to appeal to it.  Even now, at 26, I relate a lot better to people older than myself who just are who they are, rather than pretending they know exactly what a 26-year-old living in 2009 is going through and trying to tailor themselves to that.

    Bottom line: spend more time being a real person and living according to what you believe and less time focusing on on how to make it appealing to different demographics.

  • SWAurora@xanga

    When I was a teenager we had this great youth room with couches, a pool table, a small stage where the youth played the music. We had an average of 35 youth a week. Then a new youth pastor came in and decided we needed to modernize. He got rid of the couches for contemporary chairs and tables. He took out the pool table and replaced it with a computer. The youth no longer did the music, but rather the youth pastor played guitar and there were some fancy graphics from a new projector run by his wife. OUr youth group, within a matter of weeks went from 35 to 7. No one cared about this stuff and he never asked. People were upset that the couches and the pool table were gone. His thinking was that these things were distracting and we should be focused on God. So this new paint job, chairs, tables, computers, and projectors were helping us focus how? It was a disaster. I don't think teens need those things. My church now doesn't have all that fancy stuff and the teens seem to enjoy coming. It's about the company and listening to the teens that does the trick. I think we put too much stock in things rather than really focusing on what's important.

  • cutesycharm@xanga

    The youth group I was part of sucked, but the youth room and pastors and band ROCKED. No joke. It was a pretty swank environment. 

  • Choose Identity

  • Give eProps (?)

  • New! You can now edit your comments for 15 minutes after submitting.

About the Author

Who recommended?