Thursday, 24 September 2009
-
Campus Or Church Interaction?: Advice I Wish I Had In College
Since it's the end of September, I've been in a very reflective mood. One short year ago I was a senior in college, taking the toughest classes of my life. I was knee deep in GRE preparation (to no avail) and trying to live every minute with my roommates. I know that the saying goes that if I knew then what I know now I'd be ahead of the game, and its true, but I don't regret it for a minute---except when it comes to Intervarsity.During the first three years of college I was an active member of Intervarsity Christian Fellowship. I met strong Christians that strengthened me when I learned of my mother's infidelity and my parent's impending separation. My fellow Christians were there for Friday movie nights and unimposing Bible Study. If I had my senior year back, I'd race over to worship---even if I was on the other side of campus and feeling too lazy. Had I gone that final year of school, I trust that my faith in God for the future would have been much stronger and perhaps clearer, but I also know that during that year He was with me when I needed Him. He heard every prayer and answered one of the most critical.
While thinking of all the days that I squandered reading James Joyce and watching films for my independent study instead of enjoying worship at Intervarsity, I fell upon this article---thus the "if I knew then" moment. The College Student's Dilemma: Should I Get Involved in My Church or a Campus Ministry? by J.D. Greear should become the Christian college student's manual on how to maximize your experience and not end up like me upon graduation. Trust me, if you can develop that external Christian network before you graduate you'll be so much better off.
In the beginning of the article Greear lies out the four advantages that the church has, for which I mostly agree.
- Churches do have the structure and organization that you can rely on. They know what denomination they support, they know what their theology is, they know on a consistent basis what they will be preaching and how the worship services will be structured.
- Churches are intergenerational. Some days, I'm not so much into seeing the church elders, but they are a very available resource. They've lived the path and the struggles. We need to use them while we can.
- Churches are multi-faceted. This allows us to find where we best fit into the church. If I had chosen the church route during school, I would have joined the choir. During Intervarsity, worship team was a very select group and in some sense may have pushed me out the door that senior year because I didn't truly feel valued as a member of the group.
- Church is for life. Now here's where I disagree. In my experience, church during school is not forever. You have only for years, unless you plan on staying in the area where you went to school for the rest of your life, your still gonna have to make new church relationships. Sometimes you never find the right church and end up ostracized, like me, whether you're at home or school. Church is always there when you need it, although it is better to be consistent than needy and wander off after everything is perfect (churches tend to hate that).
Greear is right on when it comes to the advantages of college ministry:
- Campus ministries meet on campus, Definitely the best thing going for college ministry organizations. If it weren't for being on campus I'd probably never found faith again. Plus, you know exactly where the people that go to these events live. You can walk down the hall or the next dorm down and have someone to hang with who shares the same values as you.
- Campus ministries specialize in dealing with the issues students face while a student. Your campus worker is usually someone whose been in your shoes within the last 5-10 years. Mine were graduates of my school and almost fresh out of college---they know my professors and course load. It's a lot easier dealing with your problems in a Christian perspective when they know what you're going through.
The end of the article is the kicker! It lays out how to spend your four years: to be involved freshmen and sophomore year on campus, find a church you can consistently go to, to find a mentor at church and a few more. I definitely agree. I spent a good year silently yearning for a mentor that would nurture me in Intervarsity, yet it never materialized, and its sad to think I might have found that in a church. I spent so many days wishing that I was closer to God and stronger in my faith, but all the while I was becoming more withdrawn from Intervarsity because they weren't serving my needs. I just didn't know what I needed at the time.
As Greear approaches advice for junior and senior year he shifts focus to those who are trying to ascertain their role in ministry and that's where I got a little turned off. Not all of us are meant to spend our lives serving the church and I'd hope that as Greear revises he'd keep that in mind. I do agree that towards junior year you should be more church centered so that you can build those relationships that help you carry through senior year, but it just doesn't have to be in a ministry capacity.
So what do you think of Greear's advice? What should you be doing junior and senior year if you're not ministry minded?
Post a Comment
- Back to revelife's Revelife Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in revelife's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)
















Comments (10)
For me, I have been able to get involved with a church and campus ministry as soon as I got on campus as a freshmen. After only being here a month, I trust these people more than I do any of my friends from home. I think Grear is right by giving the good aspects of both situations.
I was in IVCF all seven years I was at KU, undergrad and grad school. It was hugely helpful and the source of my richest friendships. I don't know of any church in Lawrence that provided such substantial and appropriate training, but then again I didn't try out the Baptist church with the college ministry because I wasn't interested in a Baptist church, nor did I attend the Newman center because I wasn't Catholic. I was an active church member during those years, including the college-age Sunday School class. However, I found my mentor in IVCF, a brilliant and godly man who not only challenged me intellectually and spiritually, but also modeled what it meant to be a great husband and father. I never found anyone like him in the churches I visited nor in the one I joined.
Churches in college towns need to find ways to involve and challenge students, or else to get behind and involved with one or more of the good nondenominational student groups. I strongly recommend you get your pastor or church leaders to read The Fabric of Faithfulness: Weaving Together Belief And Behavior, by Steven Garber. (He was my college mentor and IVCF staffer.)
How can you count any time spent reading James Joyce as "squandered"?
I went to the Grear article and read it as well. I pretty much agree with everything both of you said. Campus ministries and churches go hand in hand, for all of the reasons stated as each being beneficial. What gets tiresome and frustrating is exactly when people develop the mentality that it's one or the other and cannot possibly be both.
As far as what you should do if you're not ministry minded your junior and senior year... I'd say to start seriously looking at the kinds of things you're interested in and check with your church or campus ministry to see if there's anything you can do with it and them together. For example - I've spent a lot of time in online ministry, and my last year in college, I took on the task of updating my school's InterVarsity chapter's website. Also, one of my roommates was a graphic design major, and she and another girl in her major redesigned the front of the bulletins for the church we all attended. There are a lot of things you can do and be involved without being "ministry-minded". All you need to do is jump in and ask.
I am involved with my college's campus ministry...
I'm about a month into my Junior year at University and I regret (to a degree) my first two years here in several areas. One being spirituality. My freshman year was okay; it went how I had expected it to (at least the first semester). I piddled some in a couple of churches, and finally picked one. I attended a Bible study, but didn't really get to know the people in it, nor did I enjoy this particular Bible Study, I just went hoping that I would eventually get something out of it. My sophomore year though, I didn't really like the church much that I'd chosen Freshman year, so I kind of started over and went to a few, but then I got involved in the "world" and stopped going and never found another Bible Study, so I kind of got a little lost.
I'm beginning my junior year now, as I said at the beginning of this comment, and I'm not really sure where I'm headed. I joined a HomeGroup, which I really love the concept of it, but the problem is it meets Thursday evenings and I have a conflict every other Thursday (a meeting that I am required to be at at the same time because I'm an Officer in another organization which I've been involved in for two years and I LOVE it). I haven't felt called to leave that position or anything either. So, I'm kind of back to square one though, church-searching? I'm not really sure where to go, what to do. I do go to Breakaway (look up Breakaway + TAMU). It's awesome. It's a weekly Christian "Bible Study" and it's the largest of it's kind in the nation. Last week over 7500 students were in attendance. I love the speaker, but its hard to meet people there with so many!Â
I'm kind of in a state where I need to find God on my own though, rather than listening to what others tell me about Him. That's something I did realize recently. Though, it'd be nice to have some "accountability' and fellowship. I guess we'll see how the rest of the semester goes!
Do I agree? Yes and no.
Churches aren't always reliable, because not all of them have a solid foundation, though I have been fortunate to find a church in my area that is. Denomination isn't as important to me as whether or not they preach the truth, whether or not they preach Jesus Christ. I'm also involved with InterVarsity at my college, and I'm actually the discipleship coordinator this year, so I'm going to be working on getting people who want discipleship paired up with a mentor. It's only the second year that the position has been in existence in our chapter, and there wasn't much done with it last year, so it will be exciting to see what God does in our chapter with that!My Church backs Campus Christians @ PSU (Pittsburg State University, Pittsburg, KS) and I've always been amazed by their strong international ministries, men's and women's dorms, and their strong worship services.
I admit that I've only been to 2 Churches in my life. My home church and one I visited on weeknight services for about 6 years. Both were good places to learn about Jesus. Both held people and situations that were definitely problematic at best. I've also never found a 'mentor', but then again, all I've ever really needed has been provided through a miriad of sources. Get involved with Christian people and godly works and you will find godly people worthy of your time and energy. To have friends be friendly.
People NEED the Church - it is Christ's body. If you're an eye, how will you hear without meeting with your ear? If you're a blood vessel, you need the heart to fulfill your nature and calling. The Church is a group called apart, it is a body, it is a hospital, and it is what you need. Oddly enough, a good Church needs you, too. What good is a great body when the eye, ear and heart wander away? Paul said,"Forsake not the gathering together one with another as the (missing a word) of some is" incomplete quote, but don't you get the message? Church is necessary for you to be all you can be, and you are necessary for the Church to be all it can be. Let's be together on this... because that's the heart of the matter... together with one another as we are together with Jesus as he is together with The Father. Community and communion. Love for all and all for love, and Jesus is love.
I was a part of campus ministries when I was in college. It was probably the best part of my life and the worst part of my life. It seems like there was always contentions after the group got to a certain size. The leaders were not well equipt to work with youth dealing with real problems.. The leader would tell me that I could handle it. Well,I probably had only been saved for about four years but I had spiritual discernment and gifts. I was more mature than the leaders when came to more serious stuff but very naive when it came to some of the things I came in contact with. I wish that I had been better prepared spiritually for college. I didn't have that solid christian background and I ended up dropping out of school because I spent too much time ministering to people than going to class. Looking back I wonder if my leaders had done me than I wouldn't have been caught up dealing with people in the middle of the night. I think that it important to find a good solid college ministry as well as a good church. I had both when I was doing the best in college. I don't think a college ministry is a substitute for church.
I love this post. Pretty much came straight from my brain!
I was heavily involved with my Intervarsity chapter all 4 years of school. I served on the worship team for 3 years, and now I find myself looking for a place to serve.
Luckily, I found a fantastic church my sophmore year at school and continue going there as I am only 30 minutes away from it now. One thing my Intervarsity chapter always stressed was that Intervarsity was NOT our church and that we needed to find an outside church. Intervarsity was to prepare us for the Church.