Monday, 21 September 2009

  • Do We Value Beauty Above Godliness?

    by Sharon Hodde Miller

    Preoccupied with Beauty The other day I was looking for a book at a Christian bookstore, and whenever I go I like to swing by the “Women’s Interest” section just to see what women are writing about these days. On this most recent visit, I noticed how many of the books dealt with the topic of beauty. A surprisingly large percentage of the books addressed the issue from varying perspectives: what is true beauty, what does it mean to be beautiful in the Lord’s eyes, how to fight for your beauty, etc.

    Another large percentage dealt with what I call “survival issues”–healing, managing a busy schedule, overcoming hard times, bad marriages, difficult kids, etc.  Between self-help and beauty, I’d say those topics constituted about 80-90% of the women’s section.

    This ratio made quite an impression on me. It also led me to reflect on whether this trend is spiritually healthy, given that it so thoroughly dominates the teaching that is out there. I’ve addressed the self-help phenomenon in previous posts, explaining why an over-emphasis on self-help can actually be spiritually detrimental–the solution is self-forgetfulness in God, not a greater focus on self–but what about beauty? For all the Scriptural interpretations that encourage women to embrace their God-given beauty, is it healthy to be SO focused on it?

    To be fair, there is clearly an attack on women’s beauty in our culture. Even after writing a post about airbrushing last week, I still found myself standing in line at Barnes and Noble yesterday, staring at a girl on the cover of Shape Magazine thinking to myself, “She’s airbrushed, remember? She’s airbrushed, she’s airbrushed, she’s airbrushed!” because my body did NOT look like hers. It’s tough out there, and I sincerely believe Satan has a stronghold in this regard. God created women to uniquely reflect his divine beauty, and Satan’s had a field day attacking that attribute. There have been a lot of casualties.

    Because of this spiritual war, women have sounded the battle cry. We’ve recognized the attacks, rallied the troops, and fought for our divine image. This advance is definitely a good thing. In a culture where women starve themselves, exercise themselves to death, and hook up with random guys all because they want to feel beautiful, we would be irresponsible not to address this issue. There is clearly a deep need within every woman to feel beautiful, and we ought to take that need seriously.

    However, Satan is the great Deceiver. Even in our good intentions, he can creep in and pervert them. Knowing this, I have to ask if, in our desire to address the issue of beauty, Satan has blinded us to a bigger issue. When we focus largely on restoring women to a godly definition of beauty, are we feeding into a culture that ranks beauty, not godliness, as its most valuable currency? I hardly doubt that most of the books in Christian bookstores would argue that beauty is more important than godliness (they likely teach a definition of beauty that equates the two) but is it possible that we’ve allowed our culture to define the terms of the battle, instead of God? We are stopping up holes in a leaky dam, instead of building a dam that will never succumb to leaks in the first place.

    Having said that, the real problem is not that “true beauty” is under attack. The problem is that we are not a generation of women who are immersed in God’s Word and captivated by His glory. As I mentioned above, the solution to low self-esteem is not self-help–it’s self forgetfulness in God. We must be so profoundly in love with God and His Son that our own need to be esteemed fades in comparison. My personal beauty only has significance inasmuch as I reflect the beauty of God.

    Having said that, I don’t think we need to do away with books about beauty. It’s important to equip women with the tools and knowledge to fight the onslaught of Satan’s lies. However, our primary weapon is not books about beauty. Our primary weapon is God’s Word. We need to cloak ourselves in the truth of Scripture in such a way that makes up impervious to any lie that Satan hurls at us. They’ll bounce off our hearts like bullets hitting Superman’s chest–completely ineffective.

    I should also add that I think women like Beth Moore and Kay Arthur strike this balance remarkably well. These two women certainly address beauty and healing, but the bulk of their work focuses on studying the Bible. These women know the Bible, and they’re equipping women to do the same. I applaud them in their Gospel-centered focus, and I pray it is a taste of what’s to come for Women’s Ministry. I hope that one day when I swing by the “Women’s Interest” section I won’t merely see books about overcoming marital problems and rediscovering one’s inner beauty. I hope to see shelves filled with the teachings of godly women about the powerful sword that is God’s mighty, indestructible Word. That is the answer to our beauty problem.

Comments (20)

  • Parsimony@xanga

    Doesn't an excerpt of the bible say all is vanity?

  • ChevalierSeingal@datingish

    For myself I personally do. But only because I am no longer christian and I value vanity, egoism, individualism, and extreme nonconformity. From a christian perspective it is a huge no no, but like I said I am no longer christian.

    There is an extremely great looking girl (probably the best) on my friends list who had a post today asking her friends if there was a better way to make herself puke. lol I forgot what that phenomenon was called, but I am sure you girls know. So she obviously does. And that would obviously not line up with "godliness". But that would also not line up with my selfish values either because if she loved herself more then other people she would not do that. I would consider her a people pleaser.

    Parsimony, yes I believe the bible does say that. TOOTLES! :)

  • ShimmerBodyCream@xanga

    Well your picture is one of you with makeup on and not a cross, so you do the math.

  • anonymous
  • FreeeVerse@xanga
  • subSacred@xanga

    @PD - @Parsimony@xanga - Actually, yes. Its all over the book of Ecclesiastes.

     (Some versions may say something more like "meaningless". )

  • avrilrullz@xanga

    As a Christian guy, I must say, we definitely do put a LOT of weight on girls to be attractive and beautiful.  Being realistic, I have to say, a girl has to be attractive to even be a consideration.  You may think this is shallow, but it would be a lie to say otherwise.  Any guy would agree in his heart, and if they found a girl who is not, it is a miracle of God, or they were very desperate, or thats the best they can get, so thus they had to stoop.  This sounds really horrible, I know.  But it is true, and it is one of the only things guys talk about.  I'm not saying this is a good thing--in fact, I think it is pretty messed up.


    All this to say, no matter how physically attractive a girl is, they are not who we want to marry unless they are sold out for Christ.  That is the most attractive thing about a girl!  Now if they love the Lord with all the hearts, minds, souls, and bodies AND they are physically attractive... WOW, all of the guys will be flocking to her.
    But again, if a girl is not outwardly attractive, she is not going to catch any guys attention unless they get to know her and see the inward beauty.  A lot of girls don't get this--it is very simple though.
    Because unless a guy knows her, all he can see is outward beauty.
  • ShimmerBodyCream@xanga

    @avrilrullz@xanga - You put a lot of weight on chicks being attractive and you call yourself Christian.

    Best oxymoron ever.

    but take out the oxy because that's what you are.

  • leadworshipper82

    I would gather to say that there should NOT be such an emphasis upon the physical appearance.  Though health is a necessity... but the stress of health/excersise is solely on the basis of the longevity one can have in order to preach the Gospel.


    I would also gather to say that physical attraction is important initially... but this in turn should not be idolatry nor should a guy want to treat his wife or GF as a trophy, because that is a perversity on what should be the case which is servant love...


    I would venture to say that the reason is because the Church today is taking its cues from the culture... a culture where billions are spent to improve self-image, self-esteem, self-awareness, self-preservation, self-everything; and the Church is buying it.  You wonder why we're ineffective... because we bought the lie that we can find functional salvation on looks, expensive clothes, relationships, materials etc rather than finding salvation upon Christ...


    women who idolize physical beauty are imbalanced in their focus... all it needs is a perspective shift...

  • TheSutraDude@xanga

    I think it's dangerous to choose our enemies in life and blame them all on Satan because it allows us to totally miss the problem at hand. When we look at magazines with all the pretty airbrushed females on the covers and the often superficial *trend* articles found inside, we're seeing capitalism at work. Over the past few decades the female has become the target of hugely profitable markets and she has been targeted very effectively. It's plain and simple. Make her feel like she's missing something and then tell her you've got that something she's missing and watch the profits soar. You're not alone. It happens to men too. I've been surrounded by "metrosexuals" for years. 

    I saw something very interesting last night on TV...a head on collision crash test. One of the cars was a modern automobile. The other was a car from the 50s or 60s. The crash test dummy in the modern car was well protected while the crash test dummy in the old car was not. Outside of a miracle a person in the old car would have been killed. The point of the demonstration was that without government safety regulations we'd still be driving around without the protections we see in cars today. Seat belts, airbags, mandatory child safety seats, crush point impact technology have all been instituted not because they were profitable but because of government oversight. The reason I bring this up is that there are many who still believe that when the market is left unregulated the best interests of the consumers are the result. I can only surmise these people slept through the autumn of 2008. I worked on Wall Street for one of the big investment banking firms. I can tell you the people at the top knew what was going to hit the American people long before it happened but they did nothing to stop it for years because they were able to keep lining their pockets at the inevitable cost of everyone else. Another example of the dangers inherent in an unregulated free market now appears so obvious that it's unimaginable today that it actually happened. I recently saw the video from only a couple of decades ago in which the leaders of all of the tobacco companies sat shoulder to shoulder in front of Congress and one at a time they each said "I do not believe that tobacco is addictive". Meanwhile, decades before their own internal research had proven tobacco is highly addictive.

    How does that relate to your post? You are a major target of almost uncountable markets, behind which are people for whom profit is the goal and your well being is merely consequential. The government can't regulate articles written in mags like Cosmo, we wouldn't want it to, and I doubt it's going to make airbrushing illegal anytime soon. It's up to the individual to understand one's inner worth and thereby immunizing ourselves from the 24/7 carpet bombing of Madison Avenue. 

  • avrilrullz@xanga

    @ShimmerBodyCream@xanga - you are open to your opinion, may i ask why you think this? youve pointed out nothing wrong with what i said, just merely deemed it stupid. any reason?

  • ShimmerBodyCream@xanga

    @avrilrullz@xanga - You said something was wrong to do to a human being, yet you do it anyway and don't change it. Do you not see the hypocrisy in your own paragraph?

  • Roadkill_Spatula@xanga

    There has been a trend in recent years to restore masculinity to men and femininity to women, with books like those by the Eldredges and Dalbey and the ones you refer to. It's a healthy movement in general, but as you point out, it can create undue emphasis on physical beauty for women. It can result in distortions on the masculine side as well. Not all of us guys are wired to ride Harleys or climb mountains. Participating in rowdy men's events where physical prowess is exalted can potentially have the opposite effect desired for some guys.


    Our true value and identity come from our relationship with God. And as in everything, balance and wisdom are extremely important.

  • inemesit2001

    I'm for balance. We can't run away from the fact that somehting in us wants to embrace beauty because God made us in His image. Have you heard the song 'You are beautiful beyond description? That refers to God. I believe that ugliness is alien to our nature because it's of the devil and was never part of God's original creation. Having said that, I believe we can also lose focus when we over-emphasize bodily beauty at the expense of our souls. Beauty should flow from the inside. That's the most enduring form.

  • avrilrullz@xanga

    @ShimmerBodyCream@xanga - first of all, i never said anything was wrong to do to a human being.  2nd, actually it would be hypocrisy if i were to say that it didnt matter.  because it does. and if i say it doesnt but act as if it doesnt that is hypocrisy.  hypocrisy is saying one thing, yet doing another, and im saying what we do as guys... where does hypocrisy come in?  3rd i was saying its messed up how society is today in how that is so important. but we are in this world, we shouldnt be, but we are.  4th, we are human. no one is perfect, it even says in the bible, 1 sam 16:7, "The LORD does not look at the things man looks at. Man looks at the outward appearance, but the LORD looks at the heart"


    that is God speaking. man looks at the outward appearance. its life.
  • ShimmerBodyCream@xanga

    @avrilrullz@xanga - I'm not saying this is a good thing--in fact, I think it is pretty messed up.

    we definitely do put a LOT of weight on girls to be attractive and beautiful. Being realistic, I have to say, a girl has
    to be attractive to even be a consideration.  You may think this is
    shallow, but it would be a lie to say otherwise.

    -you

    The end.

    Dumb ass.

  • ChevalierSeingal@datingish

    @ShimmerBodyCream@xanga - Hey hey hey, he may be a "Dumb Ass", but you have to admit, he is kind of cute don't you think? I say we keep him around whaddaya say???

    P.S. Do brains=Godliness???

  • KaeishaVixen@xanga

    Meh, accept yourself for what you look like, God has never made a single mistake. Be true to yourself, because at the end of the day its you who has to live in that body.

  • Unbreakable

    @avrilrullz@xanga - Your keeping it real. I don't see why someone would get mad at your comment.

    Today's society doesn't exactly like what they know but what they see. It's pretty normal, and it does suck, specially if that's all we base a person on. But I get your point, it's being realistic. Yes, it's not good to just go for the looks, but in most cases that's the first thing that attracts the eye. 

  • Unbreakable

    @ShimmerBodyCream@xanga - I don't get your point. I don't see why your attacking people on this subject. We have all judge someone physically in one way or the other. Maybe not out loud but we had thought about it, if you haven't then congrats! I've never met someone like you. I've seen many guys who are with girls who in my eyes, I don't consider them pretty  but once I get to know them, they have a great personality to back them up. Yes, I don't agree with those who straight up go for the looks but I also thing that we have the rights to be with someone that we think it's cute, just as much as we should give a chance to those who don't appeal to us. Us as girls should take care of ourselves, not for other people but because we love ourselves to the point that we don't want to be looking like a mess. 

  • Choose Identity

  • Give eProps (?)

  • New! You can now edit your comments for 15 minutes after submitting.

About the Author

  • sheworships
    • From: sheworships
    • Name: Sharon
    • About Me: Sharon Hodde Miller is a North Carolina girl, born and raised! She is originally from Charlotte, NC, and she received her undergraduate degree and Masters of Divinity from Duke University. Sharon has worked for Proverbs 31 Ministries where she was a contributing writer to the ministry’s daily devotions and radio broadcasts. She has written for Relevant Magazine’s online articles, Lifeway’s Collegiate Magazine, Ungrind Webzine, and she continues to write and minister to women all over the world about being a Christian woman in an ever-changing culture. Sharon currently lives in Durham, North Carolina with her husband, who is currently pursuing a Master of Divinity at Duke Divinity School. If you would like to contact her regarding a speaking or writing opportunity, if you have any questions, or would like to submit a blog topic, please e-mail her at sharon(at)sheworships(dot)com.
    Stats: This Week All Time
    Posts: 1 23
    Views: 333 14922
    Comments: 10 456
    View all posts by sheworships

Who recommended?