Sunday, 09 August 2009

  • Would You Consider an Arranged Marriage?

    An arranged marriage is a marriage arranged by someone other than the couple getting wedded, curtailing or avoiding the process of courtship. Such marriages had deep roots in royal and aristocratic families around the world, including Europe. Today, arranged marriage is still practiced in South Asia, and the Middle East to some extent. The match could be selected by parents, a matchmaking agent, matrimonial site, or a trusted third party. In many communities, priests or religious leaders as well as relatives or family friends play a major role in matchmaking.

    Okay, so this is probably something alien to most people, and seemingly barbaric to a large majority. However, being Indian, I have had the chance to look at this whole procedure from close quarters. It is a custom and a practice that has practically been embedded into the very mindset of most Indians. I still haven't made a complete judgement about the whole thing, not that I need to yet. But that hasn't stopped me from pondering about it in general. The pros and cons, the various aspects of the entire thing; so as to figure out whether it is something I would ever consider doing. Before that, I'd like to take the opportunity to enlighten people who aren't aware of the factors involved in an arranged marriage.

    ▪ Reputation of the family
    ▪ Vocation: For a groom, the profession of doctor, accountant, lawyer, engineer, or scientist are traditionally valued as excellent spouse material. More recently, any profession commanding relatively high income is also given preference. Vocation is less important for a bride but it is not uncommon for two people of the same vocation to be matched.
    ▪ Wealth: Families holding substantial assets may prefer to marry to another wealthy family.
    ▪ Religion: The religious and spiritual beliefs can play a large role in finding a suitable spouse.
    ▪ Pre-existing medical conditions: Two persons with a physical deformity or disability who are otherwise marriageable may be matched.
    ▪ Horoscope: Numerology and the positions of stars at birth is often used in Indian culture to predict the success of a particular match.
    ▪ Dietary preference: Vegetarian or omnivore (often automatically determined by the caste among Hindus)
    ▪ Height: Typically the groom should be taller than the bride.
    ▪ Age difference: Typically the groom should be older than the bride.
    ▪ Language: Language also is deemed to be an important criteria. The groom and the bride should have the same mother tongue. 

    In cultures where dating is not prevalent, arranged marriages perform a similar function—bringing together people who might otherwise not have met. In such cultures, arranged marriage is viewed as the norm. Young adults tend to view arranged marriage as an option they can fall back on if they are unable or unwilling to spend the time and effort necessary to find spouses on their own. In such cases, the parents become welcome partners in a hunt for marital bliss. Further, in several cultures, the last duty of a parent to his or her son or daughter is to see that he or she passes through the marital rites, and that too before a certain respectable age.

    Now for the pros and cons, as I see them. I am going to try and be as unbiased as possible, and present both sides equally.

    Pros:
    The success rate of such unions is extremely high, as compared to even love marriages. Proponents of arranged marriage believe that individuals are too easily influenced by the effects of love to make a logical choice about a decision that may determine the entire course of their lives. Defenders often cite the high divorce rates of love-marriages to establish the relative stability of arranged marriages. If potential partners in a marriage enjoy full freedom to veto persons they do not want to marry, and merely rely on their parents and elder relatives to act as trusted, level-headed introducers and advisers who have their best interests at heart, then arranged marriages become little more than a family dating service with some pre-marriage counseling. Parents can be trusted to make a match that is in the best interests of their children as they have much practical experience to draw from and will not be misguided by emotions and hormones. By matching the social and economic backgrounds prior to the marriage itself, the chances of the union to be a success are much higher as the mindset of both the partners would be similar.  The fact that my parents' marriage was arranged, and they have been happily married for nearly 20 years reinforces that it does work, maybe even more so than love-marriages. People grow to love each other, even if they were strangers before; time has its ways of fixing things.

    Cons:
    Arranged marriage is as good or as bad as the people arranging it. A forced mismatch, based on the values important to the arranger may not be as important to the parties involved. There is no love involved, well at least until after the marriage, which basically denies the entire experience of falling in love which in itself is too beautiful to miss. So I guess that's the only negative I can think of, and an extremely significant one at that. The absence of any uncertainty, the rush you get from love, the sudden and inexplicable kind; that is going to be absent.

     Would you ever consider an arranged marriage? Why or why not?


Comments (45)

  • anonymous

    NOOOOOOOO

  • AnchorsAwayx@xanga

    ummm, are you seriously even asking this?!

  • jupiter312@xanga
  • Shy___Away@xanga

    I could be fine with it if I was raised in a society that didn't value individuality, and the freedom of choice. However, since I was raised an American, an American I shall stay and say I absolutely would not enter an arranged marriage.

  • konni@xanga

    I have a friend who went back to get married to a guy in her native country whom was set up by her parents. I just couldn't do it. No way.

  • Mac_Libureet@xanga

    I would as long as it wasn't an evil uncle forcing me to marry for money...

  • too_pretty_to_die@xanga

    never.  i'm marrying for love and no other reason.   

  • xtine015@xanga

    Heck NO. How do you know if you and the other person is compatible? Just because your parents think they know everything. If you think about it, how much do you keep from your parents? Do they really know how you really are? What if you don't feel anything for that person? Will it last?  You have to feel it from deep down inside within your heart to be married. You can';t just marry anyone. It would never last. That's like marrying a stranger instead of you marrying them it's more like your parents and there parents are getting married. Not you.

  • MissPixieGlitter@xanga

    noooo. not a penguin's chance in hell.

  • proudmom87@xanga

    No way! It's chosen by men, and not by God. I wouldn't.

  • LoBornlyte@xanga

    We are created in the image of God.  Therefore our actions must be done in freedom.  Marriage is sacred, sanctified by God, the union of the man and woman into one flesh.


    Marriage must be done in freedom.

  • Pickwick12@xanga

    I would. Also, I don't believe the experience of falling in love is necessarily denied; it just happens after the wedding instead of before. This is not necessarily a bad thing. As soon as feelings start to come up, you can take them all the way instead of having to rein them in until later.

    People bring up many cons against the practice, but the truth is, it has been very successful. I believe that if the people involved have the right to say no to the prospective partner, then it's just fine. That said, I am very excited about the chance to meet and marry the American way. I wouldn't want to switch over to an arranged marriage system; however, if I had grown up in a culture that favored it, I can see that it could be a good thing if both partners are committed to Christ and to loving one another selflessly.

  • tillseptemberends@xanga

    Heck No! Because that takes love out of the equation. I am happily married and I can't imagine would it would be like if I was forced into marrying someone I didn't love or have anything in common with. 

  • anonymous

    @Pickwick12@xanga - People bring up many cons against the practice, but the truth is, it has been very successful.


    Slavery is also pragmatic and successful.  Labor costs are simply room and board. 


    Marriage is based on mutual love and sanctified by Jesus himself.  How can two people, man and woman unite as one flesh if they are not allowed to do so freely?


    Arranged marriage is an abomination.  It debases human liberty and Creation that God proclaimed as good.

  • LoBornlyte@xanga

    @Pickwick12@xanga - if I had grown up in a culture that favored it, I can see that it could be a good thing if both partners are committed to Christ and to loving one another selflessly.


    That is an oxymoron.  You cannot believe in Christ in this day and age and believe in slavery or the usurpation of free will?


    I'm telling you Pickwick, anti-Christian people like you need to be put down and put down HARD.  There is no justification for arranged marriage PERIOD.


    Christianity absorbs cultures and orders them to the Way.  According to you, Christianity must conform to whatever debased cultural values are currently in practice.


    That has Christianity backwards.  Straighten out your mind and get Christianity frontwards.

  • TRUxLIFE@xanga

    you have got to be kidding me how about over half those arranged mariages that end up with husband abusing  thier wife and leaving her no way to get out how about all those bliss marriages
    arranged marriage is totall bull shit half the time and the girl is unwilling but cant say anything in fear of what her parentsd might do if she refuses
    i am east indian i have seen this so many times before

    SAY NO TO ARRANGED!!!

  • discover_hienie@xanga

    i would definitely wouldn't want to have an arranged marriage with a guy. that would be a no! i want
    a guy that i can have a choosing to be with. if i am force to get married to a guy. i would be yell soo hard..

  • Pickwick12@xanga

    @LoBornlite@xanga - Hi, Lo! I haven't talked to you in a while. Thanks for responding.

  • QuantumStorm@xanga

    @LoBornlite@xanga - Arranged marriage is not the same as a forced marriage.

    Re: OP

    FYI - //

    curtailing or avoiding the process of courtship.

    //

    This is quite false. Especially in recent times, a one-year "dating period" is often given between the time of the engagement and the actual marriage - sometimes longer. It was taboo in the past for arranged marriages to consider such an option, but not so much anymore.

  • LoBornlyte@xanga

    @QuantumStorm@xanga - It was taboo in the past for arranged marriages to consider such an option, but not so much anymore.


    The abominable becoming more civilized?

  • QuantumStorm@xanga

    @LoBornlite@xanga - Lol, no. There is a difference between being forced to marry and an arranged marriage. Sure, the term "arranged marriage" carries a negative connotation, but that's based on perceptions of the more extreme "forced marriages" and a conflation of the two.

    And in an arranged marriage, the bride and groom still had the option of refusing - this was generally the case, even when the courtship was not present.

  • crevis05@xanga

    I don't know if I could enter into an arranged marriage, but that doesn't mean they are always bad.  Sure sometimes, the marriage is actually forced, or the husband beats his wife, but how many marriages in the U.S. end in divorce, or how many are abused.  Their are always going to be bad marriages as long as humans are involved.

    For someone to say it is an abomination is ridiculous.  Arranged marriages are culturally taboo, but it was common practice in Jesus' time.  The Apostles who were married would have been in an arranged marriage, and if Jesus was married, it too would have been arranged.

  • JJPrint3rd@xanga

    I know of a couple who submitted to their parent's authority and went through on their arranged marriage. They have been married for 10 years, and are nauseatingly-in love. I asked her how she did it, and she said she chose to love him. And he chose to love her the way the Bible says a husband should love his wife. They were distant friends before they got married, but now they are very close. She said she is being blessed for submitting to her parents.

    Would I do it? well.... Are not all marriages arranged by God? We've (my hubby and I) have always felt God brought us together, and has had His hand on our marriage and our family.

  • afreaka_boy@xanga

    Unquestioning, unequivocally, YES.

    My parents, my family knows more about who I am than I do (although at times I think differently). They have a much better sense about who I need to be looking for in terms of a spouse.

    Not to mention, my mother has yet to be wrong about any of the girls I have been involved with. (Down to the details over what problems we would have and what we would fight about!)

    From my experience, people who are adamantly against arranged marriages fall into a few different categories. The first are the ones who do not want to give up their "right" to choose for themselves. The second are those who do not trust their parents and families, and the third group are those who have never been around an arranged marriage before.

    To answer the first category. We all have to forget about our "rights" especially once we become believers. Also, guys, really how many serious choices do we have when we are in a serious relationship?

    To the second: Some of you have every right to question the trustworthiness of your families. I have friends who grew up in broken homes and in homes where mom and dad never really looked out for the best interests of the children.  For the rest of us, our parents know us better and care more about our future than we do.

    To the third group:  Get to know some people in arranged marriages. Hang out with them, talk to them. With one or two exceptions in my experience, they have the most loving and caring and honest and true relationships I have ever seen among married couples.  They have to learn to love each other, and they know how to make it work when the feelings go away because they have no other choice.

  • TheSutraDude@xanga

    I was deeply involved with the Indian community for many years. Google Ustad Vilayat Khan and Ustad Imrat Khan if you don't already know of them....great musicians who were at the core of my involvement. Naturally in that time I came to know many who had wonderful, loving, and mutually respectful marriages through arrangement as well as beautiful and happy children and there isn't anything wrong with that. I've also seen marriages of choice that have turned ugly and even violent in no time at all. I've also heard of the arranged marriages in India that ended in stove fires, a much too common way of disposing of one's wife when the man wants to remarry, often to get his hands on a new dowry. Things usually get ugly when money is the ultimate goal. Personally I wouldn't allow anyone to arrange a marriage for me....unless it was to someone like the Victoria's Secret model Alessandra Ambrosio lol. Well not really but I'd certainly be tempted to bite the bullet on that one. 

    I have a true story that is not meant to give an opinion either way. It's the story of a guy from Bangladesh with whom I became friends. He was in love with a girl in Bangladesh and she was in love with him but her family did not approve of their relationship because they were wealthy and his family was not. Her family arranged her marriage to another man. Not long after my friend met an American girl touring through India and Bangladesh. They took a liking to each other and she invited him to return to the States with her. He accepted her invitation but as he told me, the moment they landed in the U.S. she became cold toward him and in the end left him alone in NYC. I assume the reality of his being here gave her cold feet. He was able to land a job at the U.N. and as he saved money he studied photography in hopes of doing photo essays for the U.N. After a few years he decided to take a work/vacation in Nepal with the intention of photographing village life there. He was in a small village when suddenly he ran into the girl he had been in love with in Bangladesh. What are the chances? She had gone there also on a vacation to get a break from her husband. To finish the story, she went back to Bangladesh. By that time her parents had come to realize she was not happy in her childless marriage. They also came to learn that the guy she was in love with now had a good job at the U.N. The families agreed to annull the marriage and she and my friend married over the phone. She joined him in NYC months later after her immigration papers were approved. Last I saw them they had one child and another on its way. To me, theirs is the love fairytales are made of.

  • Sign in to Comment

  • Give eProps (?)

About the Author

  • niikhita@xanga
    • From: niikhita@xanga
    • Name: Nikhita
    • Location: India
    • About Me: I guess you could say I have the tendency of thinking too much most of the time. I do believe that my thoughts create my world because in the end thoughts are what truly belong to us. I am a serious person inside my head and a pretty fun person outside. I like to believe that I'm a confident, self-assured individual, but I'm still on my way there. Self actualization is something I'm still trying to achieve. I love writing, reading and almost anything to do with literature. I have vast interests and try to be the best at whatever I choose to do.
    Stats: This Week All Time
    Posts: 0 1
    Views: 0 713
    Comments: 0 44
    View all posts by niikhita@xanga

Who recommended?