Monday, 06 April 2009
-
Being Told to Have a "Quiet and Gentle Spirit" Always Made Me Squirm
by Sharon Hodde of SheWorships
If you’ve ever met me, even once, you probably know one thing about my personality–I am not shy. Although an introvert by nature, I tend to be fairly outgoing and outspoken when the occasion calls (or when it doesn’t). I’m the daughter of a go-getting entrepreneur, so I’ve tried to study and learn my dad’s leadership strengths, and I definitely have his personality.I’m not a wall flower. At all.
With that in mind, I have deliberately avoided the following verses, which have made me feel squeamish and uncomfortable every time I’ve read them:
3 Your beauty should not come from outward adornment, such as braided hair and the wearing of gold jewelry and fine clothes. 4 Instead, it should be that of your inner self, the unfading beauty of a gentle and quiet spirit, which is of great worth in God’s sight. –1 Peter 3:3-4
Now I’m totally tracking with the first verse. That’s a topic I discuss with young women all the time–the importance of not founding your confidence on fleeting, superficial physical attributes.
But the second verse–that’s the one that always makes me squirm. Adorn yourself with a “gentle and quiet spirit?” I don’t like the sound of that! It sounds like a prescription for a cookie cutter personality. In order to be a good Christian woman you have to be quiet and shy and not talk too much. You have to be compliant and meek and easy to dominate.
And that’s how some Christians have interpreted these verses. Because of this passage, strong Christian women have been made to feel less feminine or ungodly because they had outgoing personalities. They were a perceived threat to male leadership.
But that’s by no means the best interpretation of those verses. Notice that it says a quiet and gentle “spirit,” not “personality.” This verse is describing the spirit and motive that drives your personality, not the personality itself. You can still be outgoing and strong and passionate, while also possessing a quiet and gentle spirit underneath.
That said, it’s also important to note that a woman can be painfully shy and quiet, while also possessing a rebellious and bitter spirit. It’s not the personality that this passage is addressing, but the guiding compass behind it. God cares about your heart.
With all of this in mind, I thought I’d draw up a little list of diagnostics, highlighting the distinctions between an outgoing woman with a quiet and gentle spirit, versus an outgoing woman without such a spirit. Look over it and then search your heart to see which category you fall into:
With a Quiet and Gentle Spirit:
- Confident but not forceful
- Demonstrates leadership without being overly controlling
- Is driven by a trust in Christ, not a fear of failure
- Outspoken but humble
- Slow to speak, communicating Scriptural truth and wisdom
Without a Quiet and Gentle Spirit:
- Will push and push until she gets her way
- A control freak
- Driven by fear
- Always has to be heard
- Brash, quick to speak, and quick to become angry
At their cores, the difference between these two spirits is peace versus fear. You are being driven by either one or the other, and it’s up to you to determine which one it is.
So if you’re like me, go ahead and be outgoing! Be passionate and outspoken and be a leader! But do it for the right reasons. Not because you want attention or because you have something to prove or because you’re afraid of what will happen if you don’t. Do it because God gave you that personality and He should be glorified through it.
A quiet and gentle spirit does not equal a bland personality–it’s simply an anchor that enhances your God-given uniqueness, so embrace it!
Post a Comment
- Back to revelife's Revelife Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in revelife's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)
















Comments (40)
I dig this. :)
I like this post a lot.
I like your translation. not sure if it's correct though. since these passages were translated from either latin or hebrew [I think] the meaning can be unclear since other cultures [and ancient cultures] might not make a clear distinction between words like "personality" and "spirit." plus, the orders given to woman in other passages about how to interact [or not interact] with others suggests a less ideal interpretation.
but I like your positive attitude. you should keep being you.
<3
100% agreed :)
I have a quiet spirit and personality. lol
Great post.
I appreciate how you expounded on this to promote understanding, and not just to accomplish an agenda of justifying whatever personality traits you personally have.
Very well said.
Good posT ~
With a Quiet and Gentle Spirit.... Without a Quiet and Gentle Spirit... one just can't win huh? =__=
Great post, I enjoyed it!
Fabulous! Thanks for clearing up that common misconception.
@Alyxandri@xanga - Actually, the New Testament was written originally in Greek. The King James Version was a translation from Greek to Latin to English, but if you really want to know the definitions and cultural meanings of a word, a word study would be the best solution. According to BlueLetterBible.org, the Greek word "pneuma" can mean the soul or essence of a being. So, I think in this context, it's not talking about personality, but character.
When you take it in context with the passage in I Peter, the interpretation here does indeed fit the message in the surrounding verses.
Oh wow, I'm definitely shy and quiet with a rebellious and angry spirit. At least I'm in therapy.
Awesome post!! I can totally relate!!
VERY WELL SAID. VERY VERY WELL SAID!!!
I know I'm getting in on the commentary a little late, but I just wanted to say I love this post and I totally agree. This is something I also struggled with for a long time, but I came to the same realization a few years ago. I also found a lot of encouragement and explanation in the following verses:
For this is
the way the holy women of the past who put their hope in God used to
make themselves beautiful. They were submissive to their own husbands, like
Sarah, who obeyed Abraham and called him her master. You are her
daughters if you do what is right and do not give way to fear.
I found this comparison a really enlightening example of what the passage was truly about, because if I think about Sarah and other OT women like her, I am always impressed by their courage in just keeping on no matter what foolish or dangerous thing their husbands were up to. A gentle and quiet spirit is one that knows that no matter who seems to be in charge, God is the real authority, and He can be totally trusted. "Do what is right and do not give way to fear," I think is the perfect summation of what a gentle and quiet spirit is--total trust in God and willingness to do His will, which shows itself in unbreakable courage and strength of resolve. That is something any woman could be proud of. Thanks for sharing your insight!