Friday, 25 July 2008
-
The Unfair Advantage of Being Pretty
by mr pine
It's embarrassing how much significance our society puts on physical beauty. Whether it's from the makeover shows which preach that you can't be happy unless you are attractive, or from how much we faun over the hyper-glamorized celebrities, or from something as simple as tending to show more kindness to better-looking people... it completely permeates our culture. And I think most of the time we're not even aware that we do this. I think that without even knowing it, we attribute so much more to beauty than just physical appearance. It shapes our opinion of people we barely know. On some level we grant more grace to attractive people than to unattractive people.And though right now you may be thinking, "Beauty is so subjective, so you're wrong," I would argue that there has to be an objective aspect of beauty, otherwise we would not have movie stars and models and such. It may be the idealistic and honorable thing to say that "beauty is in the eye of the beholder," but I think we're kidding ourselves if we think that physical beauty is completely subjective. If you had 100 people in a room and asked each of them to rank from 1 to 10 who they think are the most attractive ones there, I would almost guarantee that there would be some that receive a large percentage of the votes... and on the flip side there would be some who may not even receive a single vote. That's the harsh reality.
But it's not even the fact that it's in the media how much better the beautiful people are treated that causes me to pause. I see it all the time in just everyday life. I see it in the youth group in how the cutesy girls are bathed in attention while the plain-looking ones are virtually ignored (by the way, youth group guys, a word of advice... some of the prettiest women I know now were complete nerds in high school). I notice that people are more polite and more smiley-faced towards attractive people. I seem to remember that when I was in my 20's that the more attractive women I knew had a fair number of male friends and they never understood why or they just took it for granted.
I wonder if people realize that they're being treated differently than other people. I've observed that attractive people have an easier time asking people to do them favors. This is probably because they're used to having people do things for them because they're attractive. But I wonder if they don't realize that this is not the norm. I think that if a less attractive person and a more attractive person were to switch bodies for a month, each would be incredibly shocked at how differently they were treated. Is confidence attractive? Or is it that attractiveness built that confidence within them?
Now I would like to go on the record to say that I'm definitely not immune to any of the things I have mentioned. I know that if I were to videotape my life, I'd be appalled at how hypocritical I am. But these are my observations. I hope that by writing them down, I can keep myself in check. Beauty may be only skin-deep, but in this world it seems to be deep enough.
Pop quiz: Who is the following passage describing?
He grew up before him like a tender shoot, and like a root out of dry ground. He had no beauty or majesty to attract us to him, nothing in his appearance that we should desire him.
He was despised and rejected by men, a man of sorrows, and familiar with suffering. Like one from whom men hide their faces he was despised, and we esteemed him not. - Isaiah 53:2-3Have you observed an over-emphasis on physical beauty in your community?
Post a Comment
- Back to revelife's Revelife Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in revelife's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)
















Comments (94)
Objective standards of attractiveness (female): symmetry, WHR of at least 0.7, healthy BMI, youth.
Objective standards of attractiveness (male): symmetry, WSR of about 0.5, healthy BMI, status/wealth.
Personally, I don't think I'm very attractive (at least facially), but I typically get treated as though I am. I am very confident in my intelligence, so maybe that's what people see. Or maybe they're going based on my body.
Almost every attractive person lives in the body of an unattractive person at some point: it's call aging.
@ChaplainDavid@xanga - Why would you repent for other peoples' decisions? And besides, non-believers, susceptible to this same logical fallacy
@bittersunday@xanga - While what you're saying is true in general, I don't think it's fair to classify everyone by those standards. Personally, the only aspects of outer appearance that cause me to form a biased judgment about someone are the things they can change: posture, clothing, gait, etc. There are extremely few people who I have ever viewed as physically attractive and extremely few people who I have ever viewed as physically unattractive before I got to know them.
Example: when I first met my current boyfriend, I didn't look twice at him. I didn't think he was attractive at all. Nearly two years later, we finally started talking (just a friendship), and as I got to know him, he looked better and better.
Example: when I first met most of the "popular" girls in high school, I had no opinion on their physical attractiveness. After a couple of months of getting to know them, I found most of them physically hideous.
When I say very few, I mean it. Something like .1% of the population falls into either category.
And my concept of beauty is nowhere near the modern American one. The ideal woman I would want to be physically? Tiny waist, generous hips/breasts, pale skin, long hair, full lips, large eyes. Surely, not everyone can be this, but that's what I find most attractive.
@Nikolais_apprentice@xanga - Exactly. Thank you! And people also consider attractive people to be more intelligent.
This goes along nicely with this Lifetime network TV movie starring
Hailey Cuoco "To Be Fat Like Me." it's about a beautiful high school
student who dons a fat suit because she doen't believe she's treated
better than an "uglier" person. and she finds out how wrong she was...
I highly recommend this flick.
@Roadkill_Spatula@xanga - the thing about fathers and daughters - yes, very true. tell them you love them and think they're beautiful, no matter what. even if they think it's gross (teenagers think everything parents do is gross and weird. we grow out of it. promise.)
It's not just our culture that glorifies physical beauty. It's been here for centuries. What is unique about this day in age, I think, is our fixation on being thin. Take a look at the statue of Aphrodite - the Greek goddess of love and beauty. She is what (we would now call) an "average" sized woman, not "thin" by Hollywood's standards at all. And yet, she's the goddess of beauty! Gorgeous and seductive... but she would never be able to get on the cover of Vogue today. Oh no.
My community is no different. Whoever has the cutest outfit or the prettiest hair or the most flawless skin are the ones that are drowned in attention. Though it's not as extreme, this goes for the men as well. Whoever is more muscular or more suave gets ahead.
Now, don't get me wrong - it's nice to take care of yourself and look your best. It's proven to elevate your self esteem and lessen depression (even clinical depression). However, society has gone overboard.
And to add, I, still to this day, do not think I am attractive. Like it's been said above, this can be attributed to my father never, ever telling me that I was pretty. My mother rarely did either... Until, that is, I started asking her if I was or not as I got older. Now, people tell me that I am very pretty, and yet, like I said, I just don't see it. So in response to some attractive people not understanding why they are flattered with attention or more companions of the opposite sex... well right there is a possibility.
I was always told that God thinks I'm beautiful, and I know that he does. Though it doesn't always work, sometimes just looking at yourself in the mirror and repeating to yourself that you are beautiful in the eyes of your Creator... can make you feel just the tiniest bit prettier.
Peace&love,
Brooke
@musicislife446@xanga - That's very true. But most people judge physical appearance at first.
Repenting for other's sins is a Biblical principal. Look at how Daniel prayed. Goodness, if someone is rejecting Christ because they are not welcomed into the Kingdom due to a false perception, you will see me on my knees, to be sure. How far did Jesus have to go to reach me?
@la_faerie_joyeuse@xanga - Perhaps I could have phrased my initial comment better. But even if it is very few whom you have judged purely by their physical appearance point blank--that is still a few. It's still more than zero, and you've done it. I've done it. Does that make more sense?
Some people do it a lot more than others, but I think it's very ingrained in our society to judge people based on what they look like. But kudos to you for not doing it often.
And I agree with the rest of your comment--I'm the same way. The more attractive someone is to me emotionally or intellectually, the more attractive they are period. If someone is haughty or ignorant I find them very unattractive, no matter how "pretty" they may be by modern standards.
It's also comforting to know that I'm not the only person who finds pale skin attractive. Yay porcelain!
@mslisachristine - Thank you for your comment and for your suggestion. I don't watch TV hardly at all, but mainly because I find most of what is on there incredibly trite.
Unfortunately, even if you cut out stimuli you cannot cut out the own nasty inner voices in your head that tell you you're ugly, fat, worthless, etc. At least, that's how it is for me. I find those voices to be more crippling to my health than any trashy magazine or TV programme.
so is the best middle ground ... an attractive person to think they're not attractive and live their life like that..
I totally agree about beauty affecting everything. Unfortunately.
The movie Shallow Hal kind of deals with this subject.
The passage describes the Lord's Servant, who is debated to be either Israel or an individual. Either way, the epitome of the Lord's Servant was Jesus, so He is fulfilled through that passage and (gasp) is the "ugly duckling."
@bittersunday@xanga - That's fine, and you make good points. Generally, just to clarify, I don't think that initially simply inherently attractive people are "better" or more intelligent. I do think that initially unattractive people are less intelligent, but that's generally because I find them specifically unattractive based on facial features that are indicative of a severe disorder/mental retardation, so it has never (so far) been wrong. Every other thing I judge on initially is based on choices, like posture, clothing, hairstyle, or makeup.
The only problem I have with pale skin is that it requires about spf 10,000 applied every 5 minutes in order to stave off sunburn. Somehow, even though my sister is a redhead and I'm a naturally-highlighted brunette, and even though our skin is the same shade, I burn a thousand times more easily than she does. She just gets freckles. I get pain and damage.
But it's still absolutely beautiful. The contrast of pale skin to dark hair (or pale skin with red hair) is amazing! I also love contrastlikethis, so certainly, pale skin isn't the only that should exist, it's just my personal favorite.
I think we're in danger of taking things to the other extreme. People who meet standards of beauty can easily become targets of hate, you know. I consider myself an attractive person, and I'm unapologetic about it. I don't put a qualifier on it--I'm not more attractive, you see, than anyone else. But I'm afraid to even put that in text because I just assume that the people who are so fed up with unfair treatment are going to think that I use my appearance to my advantage.
It makes me wonder: have I been deceived, all these years, on why people treat me well? I smile constantly at strangers--of all shapes, sizes, skin condition, facial symmetry, etc. I hold doors for anyone behind me without even checking to see who it is. I make eye contact. In response, people treat me with warmth, kindness, say "Thank you," or strike up conversations. I've always thought it was because I treated them with decency. Are you telling me that it's not the smile itself, but the straight teeth? It's not that I held the door, it's that a pretty girl showed consideration?
One should not have to feel bad for not meeting standards of beauty in this world, and I think it's a huge step that Christians are starting to see this and address it. But one should not be made to feel bad for things over which she has no control. Like many commenters, I had an eating disorder for years; would you have me swing the other way and punish myself for being attractive?
@la_faerie_joyeuse@xanga -
The pictures you linked to are absolutely beautiful!
And damn, do I ever understand. >_< I can hardly go outside in the sun without turning bright red. Apart from that (and from not being able to wear a few colours because they wash me out completely), I love being pale. I have dark hair as well (naturally dark brown, but I dyed it black a few weeks ago) and I like the contrast also.
I think pale skin is very attractive but I find dark skin (not tan skin, dark skin) even more beautiful. I grew up in Asia, and I always wished I could look like my Filipina friends. My personal standard of beauty is similar to people who are Southeast Asian or South Asian.
What a shitty post!
@haemina@xanga - even if they think it's gross (teenagers think everything parents do is gross and weird. we grow out of it. promise.)
My girls roll their eyes from time to time, but they and their friends think I'm "really cool." Partly because I'm affectionate with my kids, partly because of my weird sense of humor. They don't live with me, but I call them every day and absolutely treasure my time with them on Sundays.
Fascinating topic... I work a customer service job and in my "spare time" in between customers I actually think about these kinds of things a lot. One example: as I stood waiting one day I noticed an overweight guy walking by, and the first adjective that popped into my head to describe the way he looked was "sloppy." He was wearing a large t-shirt hanging rather far out over the front of him due to a large stomach and had khaki shorts on. However, I immediately wondered what a standard attractive guy would look like wearing the same clothes and took some time to imagine it. I came to the conclusion of course that I would not have considered describing the attractive guy in the same clothes as sloppy, which did not surprise me. It is true that people give an often unfair advantage to those who are attractive. Interesting to note however is that this message is internalized very young. I have read studies that even infants respond more positively to people who are more attractive, essentially those with more symmetrical faces and no parts that are out of proportion. Other studies have shown that attractive people with less skill are often offered higher salaries than their more skilled but less attractive counterparts. Still others showed that attractive people asking others for directions were often walked directly to the location they were seeking, while less attractive people received nothing more than brief mumbled directions most of the time. None of this surprised me when I read it, but the fact is I don't know that there is much to be done about it. Some animals even shun other animals that look different... wolves that are not similarly colored to other wolves are often not allowed to remain in packs and frequently become loners. Interesting stuff...
@HawtLindsey@xanga - i was thinking similar thoughts - that just b/c we may overvalue beauty in our culture, we shouldn't punish those who are born beautiful by the world's standards. beautiful people can't help being beautiful. our standards just need to change to include more people in that "beautiful" category and treat everyone equally regardless.
@Roadkill_Spatula@xanga - that's awesome - keep it up :) they will undoubtedly appreciate it later, if they don't do so already.
I agree. More attractive people do tend to get treated better, and that's completely ridiculous because all people are created equal, right? In the long run?
I never really think of myself as pretty. People just recently decided to tell me that they think so, and I'll admit that it does wonders for my confidence (which is pretty much nil anyway, so there's no way but up from there).
Even if more attractive people get treated better, they shouldn't flaunt it, or take advantage of those "better options" that they have because that's completely unfair.
Confidence is by far the most attractive attribute that a person can have, regardless of physical beauty.
I would like to go on the record to say that being attractive is not always that great. Especially when you don't WANT the extra attention. People assume that because you are not dog-faced, you must be arrogant. Or you are going to be unfriendly. Or you must be confident, and you must WANT people to come talk to you and have guys nearly harass you....
Every situation has it's pros and cons. Please don't assume that attractive people are secure in themselves, or that they take advantage of society.
i think attractive people know they're being treated differently, and they like it, so they maintain their looks. living in LA, there is definitely an emphasis and even pressure to be attractive.
i had a thing with this girl since last september, and she's def the definition of this confidence-jacked girls you're talking about. she's nice and all, but you can def tell she knows she's hot, you know?
thought-provoking entry, i liked it.
I used to be considered a "plain" one in high school. I was an outcast, blah blah, who cares, right? I never thought I was bad looking, though. Sometimes I certainly thought I was pretty good looking, and I didn't understand why they acted like I wasn't... it's because they knew me back when I was awkward and plain looking, in between looking cute and childish, and being who I am now. They treated me like they had when I was there.
So, though I do consider myself to be pretty, i get the opposite because most people knew me as an awkward in between and I guess they just don't want to apologize or admit their mistake?It's funny though how often people say to me "Oh you're so pretty, you're so lucky..." and I always want to point out that all my life, and even today, I'm considered a loser, and I'm not considered attractive among my peers in my area. Not all pretty people get 'pretty' treatment. Just like not all skinny people are healthy... it is rather unfortunate.I think it was amusing that the ad next to this blog was for bologon? Or something like that? Where you rate people's attractiveness?
I think beauty is very subjective in personal situations and confidence also has a lot to do with it. But as far as putting my thoughts into something cohesive, well, I think I need some time to think. I certainly enjoy what you wrote,though.