Friday, 18 July 2008
-
More Attracted to Fictional Characters Than I Am To God
by miss poppy
Lately, I've been thinking a lot about my daydreaming and the movies, shows, and books I like. I have a tendency to get obsessed. Rather than berating myself for this, I've been trying to figure out what it is that attracts me to certain types of characters.What I've realized is that I fall for the same pattern over and over again: A vulnerable female character is rescued by a protective male character. Of course, as a woman, I have a natural desire for love and romance. But I often try to live through the characters I'm watching in order to make up whatever's lacking in my own life. I don't think this is uncommon. The overwhelming popularity of romance novels is one illustration of my point.
However, as a Christian, I know that I serve a God who has promised to meet all of my needs, whether they're emotional or physical. Instead of relying on Him, though, I settle for living vicariously through the lives of fictional characters. Why is this? I believe it reveals how unbelieving my heart still is in spite of all God has done for me. If I am honest with myself, I see that I am unconsciously choosing love, acceptance, and safety that are not even real because I don't really believe that God can or will provide those things for me.
I find myself wanting fictional heroes to be real, only to realize how silly I am. If every good thing comes from God, then it must be true that every quality I love about my favorite characters-their love, faithfulness, gentleness, and kindness-must be found in perfection in God. My hero is real, and his name is Jesus.
And yet, I still expect God to be angry, harsh, and inconsistent, so I avoid time with Him and instead watch another television show or movie, trying to take the edge off my hunger for acceptance. I know the truth in my head, but my heart is unconvinced.
I'm still working on this issue, but I've started trying to redirect my thinking. When I fall for a character, I remind myself that the qualities I'm melting for are only shadows of God's perfection. Instead of letting my mind daydream non-stop, I talk to God about the things I'm wanting and needing. That way, books and movies can actually deepen my desire for God, rather than simply being things I use to numb my heart's cries.
Have you ever found yourself thinking that a person or character is nicer than God?
Post a Comment
- Back to revelife's Revelife Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in revelife's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)
















Comments (42)
"That way, books and movies can actually deepen my desire for God, rather than simply being things I use to numb my heart's cries."--that's really very insightful! I believe this is the purpose of all story-telling: to give us ideals that point us to God.
Another purpose, I think, could be to help us form our ideals so that when we meet the one God has ready for us, we recognize him. That's how it worked for me (check out my username.)
And yes, every good thing comes from God, including good men, good stories and good ideals.
@fullmetalbunny@xanga - "Women daydream about human men because Jesus is their savior- not their LOVER. If God were interested in satisfying every single whopping need personally, he wouldn't have created Adam AND Eve."
You have a good point. God certainly created men and women to satisfy certain needs for each other. He said that it was not good for man to be alone (Genesis 2:18). Dreaming about wonderful men is not a bad thing. However, I think the problem comes when women expect men to fulfill the deepest part of their hearts -- a job that only God can accomplish. We want security, intimacy, and a deep, strong, unending love. Men can and should provide this, but they cannot do it to the same extent that God can.
I don't have issues with longing too much for fictional characters, but sometimes I fall into the trap of thinking that my boyfriend (who is quite wonderful) can be my all-in-all. When he fails to meet my desires, or when I am alone at the end of the day, I realize that I am seriously lacking something. Human love cannot satisfy me unless I have God's love too.
So, it's not that it's wrong to desire men, but it becomes wrong when we place them as idols above God. It can be a trust issue, like misspoppy was saying. We have to believe that God truly loves us with an amazing (and protective) love, more than any man can. God is also perfectly able to carry us through when we don't have much human love in our lives.
this cracks me up, cuz it's so me. i have been daydreaming as well, and lately about Pride and Prejudice! haha. but you're right, God fulfills all that.
I have always loved book characters and I have never associated them with God.
i love fictional heroes... male and female... it's not that i'm more attracted to them than I am to God.. oh wait -- now that you've mentioned it.. i guess i do turn to them to escape the reality of my life. does that mean i like them more than God? do i have to give one up?
is that wrong? i do turn to God... I pray and talk to Him about things... but is it wrong to like fictional characters like mr. darcy or buffy or spike or sailormoon?
i don't really like them to be real but i do like to escape even just a few hours from my world and get lost in theirs. i'm not judging or mocking when i ask if it's wrong... i'm confused. i look up to people in revelife to talk about all things God that other christians don't have the courage to bring up in normal conversations... i look to you guys with wisdom and admiration.
i like fictional characters not for security or acceptance but because they get to do things that i would never have the courage to do on my own. they get to live in a world where they get to shine, where you have to fight the darkness to see the light, where there are corporeal evils which you can overcome. i like them because i know i won't get to have that and it's cool to be able to relate. i like the guys in the shows i love because they're flawed and human just like i am... they're just better than most guys in real life... but i've never thought they're better than God. i mean i do ask God to send me someone like that or send me the actor but it's a light request which i have no intention of realizing... is that an insult to God?
does that mean i'm trading God off for them? should i stop? is it wrong? i really am confused... and this post scared me... =( if anyone is reading this... please help...
@shanella - i haven't even read the first book! i just got "into it" (if you can call it that...) because of how much people are mocking/fangirling it on celebrity gossip forums...perhaps I should pick up a copy to see what all the ~*dazzle*~ is about XD
i think (someone may have said this before) that the christian god is not as satisfying as fictional characters because it is portrayed as male yet lacking a sex drive (something of an oxymoron). That sort of god can't satisfy all parts of human need, so something has to fill in the gaps. although, as an atheist, to me god is just a fictional character in itself.
@missmarigold - i hope you do :) you may just be dazzled
@princess_serenity07@xanga - It's not wrong to enjoy fictional characters! You don't need to feel guilty. Imagination is a wonderful God-given gift. My post was about my own realization that God is even more awesome than the fictional characters I love. That doesn't mean it's wrong to get into characters or enjoy the escape into their world. God gave us stories as a gift from Him. Much of the Bible is in story form, and Jesus told stories.
I just think that our love for fiction can be great if we remember that God is even more wonderful than any fictional character.
@misspoppy - "And yet, I still expect God to be angry, harsh, and inconsistent, so I avoid time with Him and instead watch another television show or movie, trying to take the edge off my hunger for acceptance. I know the truth in my head, but my heart is unconvinced."
This is usually the result of parent-oriented issues since they were our first gods. Only once they began to disappoint us did we begin to individuate from them. Until we can face those incidences where they hurt and disappointed us and, with Jesus' help, forgive them, we will be stuck in expecting the same behaviors from the true god. Of course, finding ways to become more intimate with Him will give you experiences that counter the previously held false beliefs about Him.
Blessings of peace and joy fill you as you continue your journey of letting Him evermore deeply into your innermost being!
@AngelBeast777@xanga - This is true of my experience. I have realized more and more that I need to separate my experiences with people, particularly parents and grandparents, from my concept of God. It's amazing to realize that God is not the way I expect Him to be. He's faithful to peel away my incorrect beliefs and show me His true, perfect love.
@misspoppy - thanks! you have no idea how much i needed the words you said. thank you for being the body of Christ for me today... *hug* =D
Ah yes...but who can resist Mr. Darcy's and Mr. Bingley?
I understand what you are saying though. And I was afflicted with the same problem for much of my life. Make no mistake...it is not an easy thing.
Take heart though! God loves to give good gifts to His children. Someday I suspect that He will bring a man along for you...that is more wonderful than anything you ever thought to hope or pray for. And even tops Mr. Darcy.
I completely agree with you. I, too, obsess over characters from books and movies. (Edward is my fav ;)....) I don't think its so much about the characters but about the time we aren't spending with God. He is a jealous God after all. When you get down to what it really is, its obsessing over somebody that isn't real. sounds like a psyhcological disease to me! lol I have tried to figure this out personally for a while now but its almost impossible to find a balance. You literally have to give it all up to God which is what your supposed to do in the first place. but that doesn't make indulging in the world of fantasy any harder to resist...especially when you've attached yourself to certian characters.
@misspoppy - "It's amazing to realize that God is not the way I expect Him to be."
You said a mouthful there! He is always, always so much better than we expect Him to be! This is the "ever opening flower" I imagine whenever I listen to "Parallels" by Yes. Ecstatic music for an ecstatic concept - God is always better than we can imagine.
It is in our fellow humans that we see God reflected. God expresses himself through us. By loving each other, we are in fact loving an aspect of God. And you must remember, that fictional characters are created by real people, and are thus an aspect of those real people, and thus are an aspect again of God. If God created everything, then God is within everything. So, to love something God created, is only natural.
All that being said, I must admit I'm a bit of an Agnostic, I don't think humanity's concept of God even comes close to envisioning the truth. I think we are all a bit "small" to contemplate something that huge correctly. I don't think any human ever alive has ever really came close to what "God" really is, not even the ones in our religious books that claimed to be close to the Creator. I think most of the books in said religious books are about as fictional as the romance novels people read, to be honest. That's why characters such as Jesus are so appealing to so many people. He is so good he can only be fictional. He does exist only on paper and in people's imaginations, after all.
And it is so very easy to fall in love with fictional characters, who can be written in an ideal way. Someone else here mentioned Edward Cullen, for example. I've been spending a lot of time lately daydreaming about him and about my name being Bella, sigh... He was written by a woman, so of course he is somewhat idealized by the woman who wrote him and even more so by those of us who read about Edward and Bella. It's natural to make fictional characters better than real people. It's a way of expressing how we wish our own personal worlds could be. And feeling for such characters helps us deepen ourselves emotionally without actually risking our hearts and minds on someone real. And if falling in love with fictional characters was all that bad for us, then there would be far less writers in the world. If "God" as you call it didn't want us to feel love for all his creations, then he wouldn't have created so much for us to love in the first place. Instead of berating yourself for not loving one fictional concept (aka Jesus or God) more than another, why not trying to open your heart to love all things more? Seek to love your God through his/her creations, since s/he is basically unknowable as any more than a concept in your mind.
And don't forget the old story about the man on the rooftop: A man was stranded on his roof, trying to escape the rising flood. He desperately prayed, “God save me.” A few minutes later, a boat pulled alongside. The boatman offered the man a ride to safety. He refused, “God will save me.” As the waters continued to rise, he prayed again, “God, please save me.” A bit later, another boat pulled up, and this boatman offered another ride to safety. Again, he refused, “God will save me.” The waters continued to rise, and again he prayed, “God, please save me.” This time, a helicopter arrived, and the crew offered him a ride to safety. Again, he refused, “God will save me.” As the waters left only the tip of the roof for him to stand on, he prayed again, “God, please save me.” The man died during the storm. When he went to heaven, he met God and asked Him: "Why didn't you protect me? Why didn't you save me? I'm a Christian, I pray to you, why didn't you protect me? And God answered, “I tried to save you. I sent two boats and a helicopter! What more do you want?”
You have to get out there and find someone to love, without expecting your God to be your own personal Lover. But there is nothing wrong with loving a few fictional characters on the side...
What is real is in a crib in diapers called the spirit thats inside us all, we keep it cribbed up and we dont let it crawl outside that crib and grow, we are immature and refuse to grow up so thats why we take on the false, the illusions as if they are real, we have words that sound real like ' I love you" but we dont have the experience of real love, we dont even know what it really means when said that Jesus Loves us, so we take a spoiled mama`s boy to think that we are being loved from him or a angry misfit , badboy type and think that is love too,
Allright then what is real love and where can we find it ? real love is not the false type and there are a thousand different false types, we can only have a chance to find it when we really give up all the fantasies of love and seek what is real and always ask that " what is real" and take no substitutions.
God is real but you must prove it to yourselfs.
rich_severson2004@yahoo.com