Wednesday, 02 July 2008

  • Question of the Day: Telling Non-Christians You'll Pray For Them - Awkward?

    oaktree the revelife crew

    pray2 Some non-Christians say they're encouraged when someone offers to pray for them. Others feel offended and a little awkward. While a negative response shouldn't make you pray for them any less, there's the issue of how (or if) you let a non-Christian know that. Many Christians hesitate to do so because their friends get defensive, others only say so when their friend confides in them a real problem, and still others don't think it's appropriate at all.

    Do you tell non-Christians that you'll pray for them, even when they don't ask for it? If you're a non-Christian, how do you feel when someone says that you're in their prayers?

Comments (73)

  • bekkathebaka@xanga

    I'm a non-Christian, and... I do feel a little awkward when a Christian tells me they'll pray for me. Because usually, if they do it for me, I do it for them. Like lend money. But praying for them... I cannot do, seeing as I'm not Christian. At least, I would not be praying to the same God that they are. I do feel awkward, but I don't find it a problem. If you're a Christian and you're going to pray for someone, you should be able to go ahead and tell them. They shouldn't be offended. 

  • Cygnus33@xanga

    Not for me, absolutely not!  But only if you mean it and really pray.  I've done this a lot, and I remind Jesus as I'm praying for that person that I told that person I'd pray, so for him not to intervene in some way, then that would make me a bad witness.  Then I ask Jesus that these people would remember what I said and wonder if perhaps my prayer helped.  Make them wonder which god it is that I serve


    It works!  I've seen these people after, asked how the illness or situation was going, and they tell me things were going better. 

  • skylar_rose@xanga

    I believe in God, but do not attend Church. This has prompted my future mother-in-law to openly tell me she's praying for me "so I can find my way".

    I feel incredibly awkward, and I'm Christian (technically)

  • AYlEENAX3@xanga

    I don't tell people that I pray for them unless they tell me to because it doesn't feel like it's needed at all. Personally, I don't think it makes a difference unless it brings their spirit up, but still I don't tell people. It's just a thing you do without saying it, like a surprise, I guess. You're doing it out of the kindness of your heart and for that person. Just let it be a surprise to them. And if something good does happen when you prayed for them, you'll know that it was because you prayed for them and it gives you that good feeling inside, that's all. (:

  • VampireOfSeduction@xanga

    I'm an atheist, and my future mother-in-law has said that she would pray for me, and so has one of my friends. Both are Christians. My response both times was, "Um... thank you." It does make me feel a bit uncomfortable, but at the same time I am grateful to them, and it kind of makes me feel special. I know they're thinking of me, in a good way.

    I think the only situation in which I would be offended is if "praying for me" were their answer to my atheism, as if they were trying to "cure" me of not being Christian. My Grandma did that once. I understand that from her point of view (only Christians go to Heaven), she's doing the right thing, but it still really irritated me.

  • kamikaze_zealot@xanga

    as a non-christian, i'm not offended in the least. i think it's a kind gesture no matter what beliefs people hold. i myself am a pagan, my mother wiccan, and my fiance is primarilly buddhist. and the three of us often pray to our own specific "higher powers" for people we care about as well. i don't see any difference in to whom you pray to for others. it's the fact that you're praying at all that matters, and that's the important thing, because it's a sign of love, affection, and care.

  • abhorrentphantasm@xanga

    It makes me warm and fuzzy to know that someone cares enough to pray for me. Now, on the occasions when I do pray, I don't tell my non-Christian friends that, most of the time. I just don't see a need to tell them so.

  • FemmeMrbd08@xanga

    It all depends on the context. I don't like theists saying they'll pray for me once they find out I'm an atheist but if I'm going through a hard time and it makes them feel better praying for me...why not?
    I'm sure people have prayed for me before and I didn't know it. I can't control someone's thoughts.
    I don't really like it when people say they'll pray for me after finding out I'm an theist and/or a lesbian but...whatever.
    I guess I can always hope they'll die soon and then we're even.

  • peace_love_compassion@xanga

    @la_faerie_joyeuse- said it perfectly. As a non-christian, I've had people tell me they'd pray for me during my hard times. In this case, great! I appreciate that love and support they are showing me in their own personal way. But ending a religious discussion with "I'll pray for you", or telling me you're praying for me to be saved is disrespectful to my beliefs and completely condescending.

  • edddDA@xanga

    yeP, i like praying for people and i do feel very awkward telling them that i'll pray for them

    well, whether they say yes or no, i still pray for them anyways

  • haleyalexi@xanga

    sometimes.
    it all depends on the situation and what not.
    first, it depends on what you want to pray for them because of.
    if you want to pray for me because I'm not a Christian, yeah, I feel very very fucking offended.
    If you want to pray for me because my mom just died or something, I'm comforted, but still feeling a bit awkward. Either way, I'd usually uoi rather not tell me unless I ask you to pray for me.
    and if we aren't friends, don't tell me either way.
    keep it to yourself.
    I get it, you're a Christian.
    I'm not insulted, but I'm not impressed.
    I'm just annoyed.

  • anecho

    Our true convictions reveal themselves in our words and actions. 

    I believe that Jesus is who He said He was ~
    The Son of God, existent with the Father and Holy Spirit at the foundation of the earth, eternally foredestined by the infinitude of His love to embody the Almighty's unitary attributes of justice, mercy, grace, wisdom, and on and on in descriptions of omnipotent perfection, the culmination of which He demonstrated in his once and for all act of sacrificial love ~ HIS love so mighty and pure that HE from the beginning of time was willing to die for HIS beloved creation.
    He purposed to come and die for you and me to show us WHO HE IS, that we might finally have a place to rest our broken hopes: in HIS greatness, in HIS mercy, in HIS awesome, cherishing, tenderness, in HIS willingness to absorb all of my brokenness into HIS perfection.

    Knowing this, my prayers are my heart and soul's communication with my Creator, as inseparable from me as my life itself - meaning, present in this body as long as I am present, and as soon as I am absent from this body, I will be present with Him.  My communion with Him is part of me, His gift to me; and HIS redeeming work in me becomes more and more evident as I believe in His transforming work.  I am not a Christian because I have put that title on my desktop plaque and continued on in life’s journey unaffected.  I am a Christian because He came to me in my utterly confounded state of weakness and defeat, He made me aware of WHO HE IS, and HE awakened a new life in me.

    I cannot offer up my prayers to others and act like I am gracing them with MY kind wishes.  Who am I?  My best is but filthy rags.  Every good and perfect gift comes from Him. 

    This is who I am because HE gave HIS life to me – He bestowed His life to live inside of me today, to defeat sin in me that I may experience every day in Him, His power, His victory.  I do not pray merely because it will make other people feel good, and I do not pray believing that I may have some influence over God with my sincerity or strength or will.  I pray in communion with, in response to, the movement of His Holy Spirit and power inside me.  I pray for the lost because HE is moved to compassion for those hurt, weary, meek and poor.  I pray because this is who I am in Him, and it is HIS power to affect change, healing, mercy, or compassion that I believe in. 

    My outward action is a reflection of the inward man (woman, in my case) ~ I live because Christ lives in me ~ I pray because He moves me to ~ and if that does make others feel awkward, it is not my concern ~ though I certainly do understand the validity of their response, my focus is not on them, but on the Lord, on His power, on His magnitude.  Before I understood, I too, experienced awkwardness at others’ suggestions of prayer, because I didn’t understand the true power to salvation in Christ Jesus, but had that kept others from praying, I would not have seen for myself.  I expect that as I am a Christian, I will act in accordance with my convictions and pray to my Savior for the help of others. 

    Others desire, and in fact have a right to expect, that someone claiming to be a Christian will in all earnestness, be praying to the One True God, the definitive ultimate power of the Universe.  They are watching to see what will happen.  The awkwardness is a result of one belief-system coming in full contact with another’s, and the explosion of real questions that ensues from that ideological confrontation.  “So, what does that mean?”  “Who are you praying to?”  “What will/could that possibly do?”  “Who is God, anyways?’ ...and on down the line of theological query. And perhaps that awkwardness may be the unaccustomed’s response of “okay, you got my attention, so what happens next?”  Whatever the case, these interactions are the true litmus test of your own convictions – do you really believe what you say, or is it just another catch phrase?  Is there power behind your prayer?  Where do your prayers go, and will it mean anything to the person you’re talking to?  Will it change their life?  If so, how?

    We are tired of weak, meager, disappointing remarks of “I’m praying for you” that are effectually powerless, helpless gestures that really mean “I’d help you if I knew how, but I don’t have the answers for that in my own life, so I’m leaving you and your problem up to God because perhaps He can help you…”  Offering a prayer as a means of shirking the true, brotherly work of coming alongside a neighbor and devoting your time and your LIFE to help each other walk through issues in truth, righteousness, and love – is a cheap disguise for a cold, too-busy-to-bother-with-your-heart’s-perplexity, write-off attitude that by all rights disheartens, disbenefits, and imparts rightful awkwardness to the hearer.  If this is the case, by all means do not say the words.  Better to be silent than to speak in insincerity.  But best of all is to allow the power of Christ to consume you, become immersed in His saving strength, seek Him until His face is all you see, and then His life inside of you will shine grace upon that one you are praying for, awkward or not.

    And ultimately, whether we tell someone that we’re praying for them or not, does not affect His power in any of our lives.  Allow the true power of the Lord to come in and administer to the other’s awkwardness.  He is real, as you place your full assurance in Him, you don’t have to worry about others’ responses ~ their hearts are His to overwhelm with Love – and He WILL – when they choose to open the door to let Him in.  J

  • wishful@xanga

    @la_faerie_joyeuse@xanga - totally agree with you.

    it's nice to want good things for people. but at times, it really makes me feel like i'm living a horrible life and i NEED to convert to Christianity ASAP!. . . .

  • the_shame_of_ucd@xanga

    I always pray for my ALL my friends. yes Non-Christian too. and I tell em straight up that I pray for them, hopefully to encourage them through tough times.

    also. I don't pray for them to become Christian or whatever. It's easy way out to just tell someone to go convert (also lame). One should leave a Christian life and lead with example to help them convert. that's what I believe. and to be honest with you GOD LOVES EVERYONE.

    and no, I don't feel awkward when I tell em that I pray for them. Why should I feel awkward?!!!

  • AirForceVirgin@xanga

    If it is a close family member or a close friend, than I am touched by their offer to pray for me. Prayer is a powerful tool.

    On the other hand, when random strangers tell me to 'have a blessed day', like this cashier at a grocery store in my town, that's when I feel awkward. I'm expecting her to say 'have a good day', in which case I can cheerfully (and sincerely) reply 'you too'. I find that I don't know what to say. If I have a blessed day, than it's because of God, not because of her, so I don't feel like 'thank you' is appropriate. Idk.

  • sophiesofiyasapphire@xanga

    In some cases its nice.
    Like if I know the person and I know they love.
    But when its from random people, sometimes it makes me feel awkward and offended.
    I was raised Roman Catholic so I understand the importance of God to people but if/since prayer has no importance to me, (and yes my life is just fine without it), then its like the person is almost trying to push their God on me.
    However, most of the time I take it as a sign of my importance in their life.

  • skeletal_figure_x3@xanga

    I am a non christian (atheist) and when people say they'll pay for me, it makes me feel weak.  It's just like saying "you can't get through your own problems, so i'm going to tell an imaginable being to help you find peace" and it just irks me when they say "I hope you find Christ"  I could think of a bunch of hateful things I could say to but I just leave them to myself.  They should just leave their own religion to themselves.

  • In_Reason_I_Trust@xanga

    If a Christiian offers to pray for me, knowing full well that I'm an atheist (though I'm currently developing my own belief system), I find it distasteful and arrogant. Yes, I do have things on my site that people could find distasteful (if not offensive) too. But, it is MY site. But, to address me personally, and offer to pray for me when you know I'm an unbeliever smacks of arrogance.

  • In_Reason_I_Trust@xanga
  • BeUnique7846@xanga

    I tell them I'll be praying for them. If they get offended I usually say, "Whether you believe in in it's power or not, I wanted you to know that I'm thinking about you and care enough to pray for you." People are getting too touchy these days. We all need to stop being so politically correct. We have Freedom of Speech, so we should use it.

  • Isismoon@xanga

    @aslgrl04@xanga - Why do you feel compelled to tell them if you know it will make them feel awkward?

  • Isismoon@xanga

    @BeUnique7846@xanga - It seems as if you are saying to to glorify yourself and not God in these cases.  You are also passing judgement about people being too touchy.  You can only control yourself, not others.  I hope that you will be more sensitive so as to not turn people off.

  • Isismoon@xanga

    I had a friend who had cancer.  She was a Christian.  But she felt as if when people made a big deal out of saying they would pray for her that they were just doing it to show their piety and to puff themselves up. Not to mention that there was a scientific study that showed that people actually did worse when prayed for!  (this had something to do with people taking less care of themselves I believe but don't quote me on it) You can pray silently if you feel that is the right thing to do.  Some people will ask you to pray for them.  There is no blanket right or wrong way to handle it except to love others and be sensitive to them.  If you don't know them well then it would be best not to outright declare your intent to pray for them.  

  • Isismoon@xanga

    @AirForceVirgin@xanga - I agree.  I noticed this past December that people would say "Merry Christmas" and then stare at me as if I was going to say "Happy Holidays" back they were going to slap me.  Things have gotten way out of hand if a simple greeting becomes a highly charged religious test.  It is almost as if people can't enjoy having faith any more. 

  • princess_serenity07@xanga

    i think non-christians feel awkward... if someone told me that, i'd feel weird too... =O

  • Choose Identity

  • Give eProps (?)

  • New! You can now edit your comments for 15 minutes after submitting.

About this Entry

Who recommended?